A Manhattan grand jury has been investigating whether Donald Trump, as a presidential candidate, broke the law in 2016 by reimbursing his lawyer for paying Stephanie Gregory Clifford $130,000 to keep quiet about their alleged sexual encounters in 2006. So far, Donald Trump has not been charged, but most observers expect him to be.
In 2006, he had been only recently married to model Melania Knavs, his third wife. Stephanie, known better by her stage name, Stormy Daniels, was an award-winning porn star.
Public revelation of the affair would have hampered a candidate trying to secure the votes of the erstwhile Moral Majority. Turns out, they didn’t seem to care. As Mr. Trump famously said during the campaign, “I could stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot somebody, and I wouldn't lose any voters.”
When news of the payment came out in 2018, Mr. Trump denied the affair. He has done so since, though on Jan. 31, he seemed to acknowledge it on his own social media network Truth Social: “With respect to the 'Stormy' nonsense, it is VERY OLD & happened a long time ago, long past the very publicly known & accepted deadline of the Statute of Limitations.” But then he later wrote, “NEVER HAD AN AFFAIR. This is old news!”
But he didn’t say “fake news,” and even his supporters have their doubts. He did pay the money after all, and he is a man known for lying.
We don’t know, and that’s the point. Mr. Trump claims the investigations are politically motivated. Legal officials — almost all Democrats — are pursuing him not because he committed any crime, but because he’s Donald Trump. They want to take him down, by any means necessary.
Mr. Trump and his supporters believe the Democrats fear his next presidential run, and that Democratic attorneys general and district attorneys hope to inflict sufficient damage to push his supporters to other candidates. (This might be the best possible development for the Republicans.)
The officials themselves and their many defenders say they seek only to uphold the law. They’re only doing their job. Indeed, they want to uphold the law in its highest form, showing that the law is no respecter of persons and that no person, regardless of wealth or power, is above the law.
Which is generally not true. But in this case, it might be true, because the former president has remained in the public eye. And despite his claims, the real possibility that his pursuers have political motivations doesn’t matter. The legal system requires the state to produce evidence against any defendant; it also requires a unanimous jury to convict him or her. Should he be tried, Mr. Trump and the high-powered lawyers who defend him will grasp every opportunity to prove his innocence. It’s a deeply flawed system, but one that should work as advertised in this case.
In defending himself, Mr. Trump will attack the legitimacy and integrity of the U.S. legal system. Whether he broke the law in this case, further eroding respect for our legal system will be another troubling legacy of President Donald Trump.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.