The city of Pittsburgh refuses to comment on an explosive allegation from a local developer, who called revamped zoning review fees “arbitrary, capricious, and improper,” as well as illegal.
Indeed, the city’s new and exorbitant fees for zoning reviews are all that — and more. Additionally, the ludicrous and irresponsible failure of the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey to explain why these new fees may be more than 15 times higher than previous fees goes well beyond its customary stonewalling of the media in general and Post-Gazette in particular.
The city’s refusal to answer a simple question about the fees it charges shows a shocking arrogance and wanton disregard for the public that city government is supposed to serve. The administration’s indifference to the most basic principles of open government is astonishing and possibly unprecedented.
Illegal tax
Unless there are some bizarre circumstances the public doesn’t know about, the city’s fee increase is unquestionably illegal: It charges an amount that greatly exceeds, by any sound measure, the cost to deliver the service. As such, it is an unauthorized tax that the applicant is permitted to recoup, plus interest.
In a letter to Pittsburgh Solicitor Krysia Kubiak, attorney Jonathan Kamin, representing Shadyside-based developer Walnut Capital, urged the city to suspend enforcement of the new fee schedule, established in January. The developer plans to build apartments and a hotel on Halket Street, between Louisa Street and Forbes Avenue in Oakland.
Under the new fee schedule, Mr. Kamin estimated the zoning review, based on the size of the project, would cost the developer $255,000. That’s a quarter of a million dollars for a zoning review. The fee for the same service last year would have amounted to less than $15,000, he said.
The new zoning review schedule charges $3 for every $1,000 of project cost, with a minimum charge of $100. Last year, the city charged a flat fee, based on the application. The city requires 40% of new zoning review fees to be paid at the time of application, and the rest before permits are issued.
An informal survey of similar fees charged in Philadelphia, Columbus, Cleveland and Indianapolis, found that Pittsburgh’s fees were about five times higher, Mr. Kamin said.
Pennsylvania law prohibits municipalities from charging fees for issuing licenses or permits to raise revenue. Any amount collected should cover the municipality’s actual costs associated with a new zoning review — and nothing more. By that criteria, the city cannot, conceivably, justify a quarter-of-a-million-dollar fee. Mr. Kamin said the $255,000 charge for the zoning review would exceed the annual salaries of the people reviewing the application.
Imperial silence
The city responded with its customary, imperial silence. Corey Layman, the city’s zoning administrator, declined to comment, and referred questions to Maria Montano, Mayor Ed Gainey’s spokeswoman. Ms. Montano did not return an email or phone call seeking comment.
It doesn’t take a judge to sort out this legal dispute: The law is clear, as Mr. Kamin noted: Municipalities can’t use the fees to generate revenue. “The fees are to be related to the actual cost of the administration of the program,” he said.
Aside from the troubling ethical and legal problems raised by the increase, the new fees add an unreasonable cost to development in the city, and will almost certainly deter needed investment. Rising interest rates and high construction costs are already discouraging developers.
The Gainey administration has not explained its excessive increase in zoning review fees. Nor has it said whether the city plans to refund fees, with interest, that exceed the costs associated with zoning reviews, as state law demands.
City government should be in the business of transparency. But the Gainey administration continues to operate behind a curtain of silence.
In truth, explaining an irrational increase like this one, at least to anyone’s satisfaction, would be futile, anyway.
The best course for the Gainey administration now is to set a reasonable raise, if necessary, in zoning review fees — then return the difference, with interest, to anyone who has already paid these ridiculous and illegal fees.
Silence won’t make this dispute right.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.