An emerging plan to provide free parking in Downtown Pittsburgh is a step toward making the urban core competitive with suburbia.
A proposal from the Downtown Neighbors Alliance — promoting Downtown as a neighborhood, not just a jobs center — would help. The alliance and participating merchants and restaurants would each pick up a third of the cost of parking. The parking companies, including the Pittsburgh Parking Authority, would take the last third as a loss. Participating businesses should recoup their investment in added business, and the parking companies would get enough extra cars to offset the 33% write-off.
The plan, or something like it, should work. One risk is that parking companies might hike their rates, and leave them higher once the promotion ends. Any agreement would have to lock in rates to ensure price stability.
The greatest asset of a vibrant downtown is its density. The ability to walk from a boutique to a restaurant to a show, or from a residence to an office and then to happy hour, is nearly impossible to replicate in suburban sprawl.
But the density of a downtown also creates a problem: Spots for private automobiles are at a premium. Parking prices become the cover fee for enjoying the amenities. When Downtown is thriving, economically and reputationally, that’s not a bad deal. But when Downtown is struggling due to a pandemic hangover, or a perceived public safety crisis, it becomes a barrier.
Nor will Downtown ever compete with suburbia on parking alone. It’s simply easier to park a car at a strip mall, no matter the fee.
Parking incentives shouldn’t derail a more important long-term improvement for the vibrancy of the Golden Triangle: Reliable, efficient and convenient public transit — buses and trains that capitalize on Downtown’s assets and advantages.
And public transit will have to be reliable, efficient and convenient to attract so-called choice riders — people with cars and other mobility options. It’s easy for transit agencies like Pittsburgh Regional Transit to enter a vicious circle by reducing service in response to declining ridership, which only depresses ridership further. If you want a transit system lots of people use, you have to build one lots of people want to use.
With the expiration of Act 89 funding from the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, one of Gov. Josh Shapiro’s biggest challenges will be figuring out how to fund transit in a sustainable way — not just to maintain current service, but to expand it.
Free parking will help Downtown, but the best long-term investment in the Golden Triangle is robust transit that will enable people to get around Downtown, and the entire city, without their cars.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.