City Council members appear poised to take a leadership role in combatting violence in Pittsburgh. That’s encouraging, given the lack of effective leadership from the mayor’s office.
But a proposal by Council President Theresa Kail-Smith — reinstating a citywide youth curfew — would take a step in the wrong direction. Council members should focus their efforts on initiatives with proven success.
Youth curfews became popular during the get-tough-on-crime era in the 1990s. Since then, thousands of studies have concluded, almost unanimously, that they have no demonstrable effect on violence.
A 2015 study of Washington, D.C., even found that gunfire increased during the curfew, possibly because empty streets meant no witnesses. Studies have also concluded that most juvenile violence occurs just before or after school, not during curfew hours.
Curfews can also carry unintended consequences, including funneling kids into the criminal justice system, eroding police-community relations and disproportionately affecting children of color. A curfew would be expensive and difficult to enforce, whether or not Pittsburgh Police did it.
Ms. Kail-Smith’s bill would bring back a rarely enforced citywide youth curfew law that took effect in 1995. It bars children under 17 from public places or businesses after 10 p.m.,11 p.m., or midnight, depending on the day and month.
Ms. Kail-Smith’s proposal also calls for several city-run resource centers that would provide counseling and other services to young people who violated the curfew. If approved, the resource centers could open, with the curfew imposed, by May 31.
Pittsburgh reported 71 homicides in 2022, the highest in 15 years. Nine victims were aged 17 or younger.
Ms. Kail-Smith is attempting to do something about the rise in violent crime, but she and other City Council members should seek more effective, grassroots solutions. Training and hiring youth to become conflict mediators and violence interrupters in their own neighborhoods could help, as could expanding hours at rec centers.
Whatever the Council does, it must work closely with community groups and engage young people, as well as people who live in, or at the margins of, the culture of violence. An effective peace plan should recruit former offenders who have turned their lives around and know how to intervene before violence occurs, change lives before it’s too late, and bolster ties between the police and community.
Long-term changes include more effective gun regulation, jobs, education, and mental health care. But there are interventions the city should take now. Ms. Kail-Smith deserves credit for starting the council’s conversation on combatting violence. Now it’s time to redirect it to solutions that really work.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.