Amelia Ferrell Knisely did her job as a reporter for West Virginia Public Radio: She investigated credible allegations that the state was abusing people under its care with intellectual disabilities.

Serving as watchdogs for the public is what reporters are supposed to do. Shamefully, by all available evidence, she was punished for it. After a high-level state official put the screws on the radio station’s leadership, the station yanked Ms. Knisely from her beat and, later, deactivated her office keycard.

This is the kind of stuff you’d expect in Russia. It was wrong for the state to bully the station, after one of its reporters uncovered abuse by a public agency, but it was even more outrageous that the station caved into the pressure. For the state’s public broadcasting agency to acquiesce to bullying undermines its credibility and mission to provide honest, independent reporting on news that matters to the people of West Virginia.

Now, a healthcare scandal has become a press freedom scandal. The leadership of West Virginia Public Broadcasting (WVPB) — the state agency that oversees public television and radio — ought to account for their decisions before the state legislature.

Advertise with us

In truth, Ms. Knisely should have been congratulated for her work.

On Nov. 3 of last year, she revealed that a bipartisan group of state senators, led by Republican Senate President Craig Blair, had sent a detailed letter to the state’s Department of Health and Human Resources (DHHR) alleging wide-spread abuse of patients with disabilities in the state’s care system. The letter further claimed the department had failed to be transparent with the legislature about these and other instances of mistreatment.

The alleged acts included requiring patients to urinate and defecate outside for months; an instance of inappropriate nutrition resulting in the death of a patient; and the refusal of care workers to perform CPR on a patient who later died.

Over the next month, Ms. Knisely continued to report on the problems facing DHHR, including announcements by Republican Gov. Jim Justice and DHHR Cabinet Secretary Bill Crouch that staff and structural changes to the department would soon improve performance. Then, on Dec. 5, Ms. Knisely reported that the Civil Rights Office of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services had opened an investigation into discrimination against people with intellectual disabilities by DHHR. Mr. Crouch retired as secretary of the department on Dec. 12.

Before he did, however, as pressure on DHHR mounted, Mr. Crouch demanded a “complete retraction” of Ms. Knisely’s reporting about DHHR, the Associated Press reported. And in early December, after revealing the federal probe into the department, Ms. Knisely said she was told by her news director that she could no longer cover DHHR because of official threats to “discredit” the public broadcaster. By Christmas, her office keycard had been deactivated.

Advertise with us

Mr. Crouch is gone, but the investigations into DHHR will continue. Now the state legislature should add another investigation, this one into WVPB, to ensure its current leadership is maintaining its commitment to independence. Those are always the wages of a cover-up: The scandal grows. It never shrinks.

As for Amelia Knisely? She’s now reporting for the Register-Herald in Beckley, W.Va. And her beat includes the DHHR.