By the numbers, Downtown crime isn’t worse than before the pandemic. But the numbers don’t tell the whole story. The city’s reluctance to police small-scale offenses and other quality-of-life issues Downtown is contributing to a sense of impunity among lawbreakers — and leading office workers, residents and visitors alike to wonder whose side the city is on.

Mayor Ed Gainey and his administration should stop deflecting to the stats and heed the pleas from civic leaders, business owners and everyday Pittsburghers to do more to address the declining situation Downtown.

But is the Downtown scene really in decline? Or is that a false perception?

On the one hand, official crime rates are stable; restaurants are doing well; and ticket sales at cultural events are on the rebound. Developers are purchasing and converting office space into apartments as demand for living Downtown remains strong.

Advertise with us

On the other hand, the total number of Downtown visitors, whether commuters or one-off visitors, is still down dramatically from 2019. That means that even if crime rates are comparable to 2019, those offenses are occurring amid a smaller amount of legitimate activity. It feels like there’s more crime — and, relative to office workers and theater goers, there is.

Further, anybody who spends ample time in the Golden Triangle knows that in recent months the city has tolerated more minor lawbreaking, which means crime rates are likely artificially depressed. There are good intentions behind this enforcement shift, but maintaining both the reality and perception of order is essential to Downtown’s functioning as the economic and cultural engine of the region.

It is also a neighborhood full of wide public spaces and nooks and crannies, a combination that lends itself both to people looking to create trouble and to people with illicit business. A visibly hands-off approach from the city will encourage more people with bad intentions to make bigger trouble, and conduct bigger illicit business — like the open air drug market on Ft. Duquesne Boulevard the city tolerated for far too long.

As fewer people with legitimate interests in the Golden Triangle make the trip — and others fill the void — what might have begun as a questionable perception of Downtown danger becomes reality. That’s the spiral that Downtown stakeholders desperately want to avoid — and that Mr. Gainey needs to take seriously.

The Gainey administration is taking some action. The Second Avenue Commons shelter is a humane response to homelessness — but it’s already full. The city says it’s beefing up foot patrols and supplementing the Downtown police presence with alternative responders who can assist with calls involving homelessness, mental health and drugs. And the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership is working with police to create a program of unarmed “public safety ambassadors” who can reassure commuters and visitors that official eyes are on the streets.

But these moves are either long-term or small-scale. Everyone who cares about Downtown, which should be all of southwestern Pennsylvania, needs to hear a commitment from Mr. Gainey that the city will never allow itself to lose control of the Golden Triangle. That means enforcing the law — all of it — to make sure lawbreakers and troublemakers don’t come to think anything goes. There’s no time to waste.