City residents have reason to be skeptical about the budget proposal submitted by Pittsburgh Public Schools leaders last week, calling for no increase in the tax rate.

If that sounds familiar, it should. Board members did the same thing last year, before turning around in December and approving, by a 5-4 vote, a 3% increase in the tax rate, the maximum allowed under state law. School Board members also tried this stunt in 2020, when they floated a 2.6% increase, but a majority of the board sensibly rejected it.

This time around, we’re asking board members to play it straight with the public. They’ve proposed a budget with no increase in the tax rate. Don’t even think about approving a tax increase next month. Any board member who tries those shenanigans again should lose his or her seat to a candidate with more integrity.

Last year, then-new school board member Gene Walker made an apt analogy: Given PPS’s structural challenges, tax hikes are “like putting a Band-Aid over a torn ACL.” It might look like you’ve done something, but the underlying injury worsens due to negligence.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Public Schools are overbuilt and overstaffed. During last year’s budget debates, the district reported a 55% use of facilities. Since 2015, staff had increased 14% and enrollment had decreased 15%. These troubling trends haven’t changed. It may be possible, through hard work and smart strategies, to achieve a minor resurgence in enrollment, but it will likely never return to the levels of even a decade or two ago.

The challenge facing the board and Superintendent Wayne Walters, who has acknowledged the district’s structural problems while remaining upbeat about its future, is not to try to maintain the status quo by tweaking the system. The task now is to rethink public education in Pittsburgh. At the core is right-sizing the district’s real estate footprint.

The district can take a cue from the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh. The church’s real estate restructuring, while painful for many people who were committed to their local and ancestral parishes, has cut costs and bought some time — at least a decade or two of stability — for church leaders to figure out what’s next.

These tough talks, not wrangling over stealth tax increases, need to dominate the debate among PPS board members. Anything less else would disregard their obligations to the city’s taxpayers and, even more important, to Pittsburgh’s students now and for generations to come.