The Pittsburgh Penguins negotiations to redevelop the Lower Hill and build a new Live Nation concert hall continue at an appallingly slow rate. But there’s a glimmer of hope.

In a symbolic gesture, the Pens have agreed to hand over some of the land to the Bethel AME Church, once a thriving place of community and worship. The church’s old home, built 1845, was bulldozed in the 1950s when the Urban Redevelopment Authority used eminent domain to seize it. Since then, the congregation has vigorously sought justice for losing its home.

Now, the Pens have agreed to return some of the land in the Lower Hill to the church, along with the development rights to the new plot of land. If they actually follow through, it’s a gesture of good faith to a community that has faced appalling treatment for many decades.

The church won’t necessarily get back its original space. And nothing will replace the original sense of community that permeated the building, a Romanesque-style church that could hold nearly 2,000. Nevertheless, the church will get an opportunity to move back to the Lower Hill from its displaced home in the Middle Hill, where church leaders said building membership was more difficult due to its less central location.

Advertise with us

Details are still being worked out.

It’s time for Pens leadership to put their money where their mouth is. For more than a decade, they’ve worked with the city and community stakeholders to produce a plan to develop land between the Hill District and Downtown. The Post-Gazette has called for an independent investigation into the embarrassingly slow pace of development.

At a meeting between the Pens developers and Hill residents, after news of the church deal became public, many long-time residents expressed frustration with the Pens, arguing that a shiny new concert hall isn’t as beneficial as affordable housing or more direct investment in the neighborhood. More meetings are scheduled.

There’s a difference between returning land taken in bad faith and paying reparations to the community. The latter, which the Pens have agreed to consider in the form of a parking and concert ticket surcharge, is a broader issue confronting the entire nation. We hope they’ll consider that proposal in good faith as part of fulfilling the obligations they accepted in the original community benefits agreement over a decade ago.

Returning land to Bethel AME, on the other hand, is an important symbolic gesture that can and should be done as soon as possible. Having dangled it publicly, the Pens must act quickly to show they’re serious about acknowledging community needs moving forward.