The Allegheny County Jail has become a toxic mess. Nothing short of a community-wide campaign — including the Jail Oversight Board, activists, local courts, and mental health and drug treatment agencies — can clean it up.

Troubles at the jail have finally grabbed the attention of County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, who in August authorized an external review of jail fatalities. Without a culture of accountability, transparency and cooperation, however, the dysfunction, incompetence and indifference at 950 Second Avenue will likely persist. The jail’s litany of woes includes numerous allegations of prisoner abuse, excessive use of solitary confinement, violating federal reporting requirements for inmate fatalities, numerous health code violations, mounting legal costs, withholding medical records, and a prisoner death rate that doubles the national average.

Making matters worse, Warden Orlando Harper’s autocratic management style has aggravated chronic staff shortages and turned the jail into a veritable fortress, marked by continual bickering and poor communication with the public and Jail Oversight Board.

Since April 2020, 17 Allegheny County Jail prisoners have died. On Sept. 21, Anthony Talotta, an intellectually disabled man, became the sixth prisoner to die this year. Following a medical emergency, Mr. Talotta, 57, died at UPMC Mercy Hospital, the day after a physician cleared him to remain in his cell.

Advertise with us

Horrific conditions

The jail holds roughly 1,500 prisoners, and nearly 10,000 people enter and leave it every year. Most are pre-trial detainees, without convictions and often too poor to make bail.

In a jail survey released last month, conducted by the University of Pittsburgh School of Social Work, inmates reported meals crawling with roaches and showers with bugs and mildew; the withholding of essential medications; inadequate food, hygiene products and medical care; shivering temperatures; exorbitant commissary prices; and corrections officers who verbally and physically abused them. Nearly 90% indicated they went to bed hungry.

Mistreating prisoners and employees has cost Allegheny County $14 million from prisoner and employee lawsuits during Mr. Harper’s 10-year tenure, Bethany Hallam, of the Jail Oversight Board, said Thursday. That’s enough to pay for more than an additional 120 employees for a year.

This month, a federal jury awarded former Allegheny County Jail Capt. Jeffery Kengerski nearly $1 million in damages, after he was fired in retaliation for reporting his supervisor’s racist comments. In June, the county agreed to pay former inmate Jules Williams, 42, a transgender woman, $300,000, after housing her with a male sexual offender who sexually assaulted her multiple times. Jail staff placed her in male housing units, even though she possessed a state ID and insurance coverage that identified her as a woman.

Advertise with us

Instead of fixing problems,  Mr. Harper has dismissed, denied or downplayed them. For months, he deflected criticism of the jail’s high death rate by arguing — wrongly — that Allegheny County’s rate was below the national average.

Communitywide solutions

Allegheny County’s jail, like most others, holds many people who don’t belong there, which worsens conditions. That’s not the jail’s fault: It takes the people sent there by the courts. Broader social problems, such as the widespread use of probation detainers, onerous cash bails, and growing numbers of mentally ill and addicted prisoners, require institutional and policy changes in the community, courts, and criminal justice system.

Resolving broader, systemic issues will take coordinated efforts by the jail, Oversight Board and community. Former prisoners and their families must have a voice in these reforms.  This month, the Black Political Empowerment Project also recommended that a community coalition tackle longstanding problems at the jail.

Allegheny County has contracted with the National Commission on Correctional Health Care to investigate jail fatalities. The $76,400 contract runs through June 30 of next year, county spokesperson Amie Downs said Tuesday. The initiative by Mr. Fitzgerald is promising — but only if the jail follows NCCHC recommendations and works transparently with the public and Jail Oversight Board.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harper is not the man for the job. He has worked his way up through the ranks and run effective education and prisoner reentry programs. But he has also alienated his staff and the public, and lacks the management skills to direct the jail’s 560 employees.

In July, the Post-Gazette called for Mr. Harper’s resignation, as have the employees’ union and many members of the public. If Mr. Harper remains, Mr. Fitzgerald will have to, during his final year in office, make the jail his top priority and help lead a communitywide campaign to clean it up.