What does Michael Bloomberg have against the people of the Ohio Valley? He’s a long-time supporter of the so-called “free trade” policies that contributed to the collapse of the industries and communities of the region. And now he’s pledging nearly $100 million to try to stop the kind of economic development that would help those communities get back on their feet.
Mr. Bloomberg’s attempt to use his wealth to impose his will on the people of the Ohio Valley is exactly the kind of elite behavior — impractical, vain, contemptuous — that is driving ordinary people to the political extremes, on the left and right. He needs to butt out, now.
The Manhattan billionaire’s $85 million pledge is going to a campaign called Beyond Petrochemicals, based on the Sierra Club’s Beyond Coal campaign, which is said to have contributed to the closure of dozens of coal-powered plants around the country. Its aim is to stop 120 petrochemical projects, like Beaver County’s ethane cracker plant, from ever starting. The website of Bloomberg Philanthropies specifically identifies Ohio, West Virginia and western Pennsylvania as targets.
It would be one thing if Mr. Bloomberg also pledged to use some of his vast fortune to invest in alternative economic opportunities for the Ohio Valley — green tech and carbon capture and other industries that can bring family-sustaining jobs to workers of various skill and education levels. But there’s nothing actually “beyond” in the Beyond Petrochemicals campaign: It’s all about fighting to stop development, including through litigation and lobbying, without any positive vision for the region.
The economic benefits of petrochemicals aren’t just in the plants themselves but the upstream and downstream businesses that rely on them. Blocking a petrochemical plant also blocks everything from manufacturing facilities that use the plant’s products to pizza shops that feed the workers. Without an alternative, Mr. Bloomberg’s vision consigns these communities to ruin.
To be sure, petrochemicals are not an economic cure-all, and there’s no question they come with environmental costs. Community and environmental groups — and, most of all, state and federal environmental protection agencies — must remain on high alert and keep the corporations accountable. To the extent that Mr. Bloomberg’s funds will enhance that accountability, they are welcome.
Read More
But he goes far beyond that, trying to impose a vision cooked up in a Manhattan skyscraper on a region he’s probably never seen with his own eyes.
An authentic economic and environmental strategy for the Ohio Valley doesn’t take anything off the table. It’s an all-of-the-above approach that tallies the costs and benefits of every proposed industry or facility, and uses current resources while planning for a greener future. It’s a vision that will require hard work and cooperation — and some conflict — among community groups and governments and agencies and corporations to make a reality.
What it doesn’t need is (another) meddling New York billionaire trying to use his wealth to tip the scales in his favor.
Correction: The original version of this editorial misstated the type of plant being built by Shell in Beaver County. It is an ethane cracker.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.