Pennsylvania’s ad hoc system of organizing debates between candidates increases the likelihood that the debates themselves will become campaign issues. The usual system in Pennsylvania involves independent news and civic organizations, usually local television stations, issuing invitations to major candidates. Their campaigns then negotiate which invitations they’ll accept and the terms of engagement.

What is the problem with the system? It encourages political game-playing, which does not serve the voters who deserve the chance to see the candidates speak. Two examples have already appeared: The ad hoc system isn’t always fair to both candidates (or felt to be fair, which is just as important) and it can be manipulated by one or both candidates.

Republican gubernatorial nominee Doug Mastriano distrusts everything he associates with the political establishment, especially media. He and his supporters believe he has good reason. He’s proposing a pair of debates with his Democratic opponent, Josh Shapiro, with terms negotiated only between the campaigns, and with each campaign picking one moderator each.

Mr. Shapiro, for his part, presumably not interested in submitted to the moderator his opponent nominates, called the proposal “unserious.” Mr. Mastriano’s attempt to sidestep the usual process, and Mr. Shapiro’s refusal to play ball, may result in an impasse — and no debates at all.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the Republican candidate for U.S. Senate, Mehmet Oz, is leaning into the traditional debate system. He has accepted all five invitations to debate, and is challenging Lieutenant Governor John Fetterman to do so as well. Mr. Oz is presumably unconvinced that Mr. Fetterman is firing on all cylinders after the traumatic stroke he suffered in May, followed by a three-month hiatus from public campaign events, and is leveraging the state’s chaotic debate system against him.

In both cases, the debates themselves are shaping up to be major campaign issues. It’s tedious, and it does not serve the voters.

Faced with similar problems, several states have created state debate commissions. Indiana’s is the oldest, dating to 2007. Utah and Ohio have followed suit. The boards of these organizations typically consist of media executives, civic-minded business leaders and respected academics. The commissions ensure that there’s a single, professional organizing entity for debates. They can ensure all Pennsylvanians can watch them by broadcasting the debates on multiple television stations and streaming platforms.

The commission system isn’t perfect. It can’t do anything about candidates who just say no. In Ohio, Republican Gov. Mike DeWine may not accept the Ohio Debate Commission’s invitation to debate his Democratic opponent, and there’s nothing the ODC can do about it. But having a highly respected statewide organization run the debates, rather than individual television stations, raises the political costs of refusing.

Pennsylvania’s system has worked, but not nearly as well as a system with such an important job should. An independent commission could only help. Pennsylvania media, business and academic leaders — as well as both parties — should collaborate to create such a commission to minimize the public squabbling over debates.