Perhaps nothing expressed the optimism of turn-of-the-century America more than the Chautauqua Movement. It began in 1873 as a lakeside retreat for Methodist ministers on the shores of Lake Erie in Ohio, while the most famous Chautauqua was founded a year later in western New York, about 150 miles north of Pittsburgh. Soon the concept, broadened to adult-education summer camps centered on academic lectures and social-gospel sermons, spread across the country, attracting tens of millions of Americans until its decline during the Great Depression.

While the events and organizers themselves rarely took political positions, the Chautauquas were progressive. They provided venues for some of the great social reformers of the day, from Hull House founder Jane Addams to prison reform advocate Maud Ballington Booth, to spread their stories and messages. The idea was steeped in a distinctively American kind of optimistic liberalism: Through education received from the best and brightest, every American could become a better citizen and a better person.

How bitterly ironic, then, that Salman Rushdie would be attacked at a birthplace of such a movement.

Mr. Rushdie published “The Satanic Verses” in 1988 to critical and popular acclaim. Despite its flashy title, the book isn’t lurid or sensationalistic. The title refers to an Islamic tradition that the prophet Muhammad was tempted by demons to add idolatrous (“Satanic”) verses to the Qu’ran, but later removed them. Mr. Rushdie adapted this legend for lengthy dream sequences in a book that was mostly about the immigrant experience in the modern United Kingdom.

Advertise with us

The next year, the supreme leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, issued a fatwa, or judicial ruling, claiming that for his “blasphemous” treatment of Islamic teaching Mr. Rushdie’s life was forfeit and faithful Muslims around the world were honor-bound to kill him. A large reward was offered. For the next several years, he lived under police protection in the U.K. Eventually, the danger of the fatwa seemed to fade, and he lived a more or less free life in the United States.

But last Friday during an appearance at the Chautauqua Institution, a man presumably inspired by the fatwa tried to kill him, gravely injuring him with a knife. Henry Reese, co-founder of Pittsburgh’s City of Asylum organization for persecuted writers, on whose board Mr. Rushdie sits, was also injured, though less seriously.

Notably, the accused assailant is a 24-year-old American — born in this country nearly a decade after the Ayatollah’s death sentence. It is a stunning and tragic rebuke to the vision of progress — toleration, open discourse, free expression — embodied by Chautauqua.

In a time of so much American self-doubt, we can look to the Chautauqua Movement as an example of the very best of American liberal principles. But the value of those principles is not self-evident. We need to live them out faithfully — first of all among ourselves — as a witness to a world increasing in thrall to extremism.