You can get paid for speeding. Maybe for having a light out. “There are so many people out there getting beat up by the world, and when they get pulled over by law enforcement, it feels like the end of the world to them,” said Jefferson police Officer Andrew Sherman, in Abby Mackey’s report from rural Jefferson Township, on Rt. 62 between Mercer and Sharon.

If they think the situation warrants it, instead of a warning or a ticket, the town’s four policemen give drivers a $10 gift certificate to Jones’ Burgers ‘n Shakes. The restaurant’s owner, Christopher Miller, donates the cards. “It’s an investment in our neighbors,” he said.

It’s a good story. The forces of law and order don’t lay down the law. They show mercy instead. Instead of a fine and points off your license, you and a couple other family members get an ice cream cone. Small town America at its best.

The practice unfortunately doesn’t scale very well. What works in a small town won’t necessarily work in the suburbs or the city. Allowing too much discretion in public administration always ends with people doing favors for their friends, but not for others. This happens especially when unconscious racial and other prejudices affect their judgment, as Barbara Held explained in “In some schools, children get police tickets for misbehavior. Black children get more.”

Advertise with us

Part of the policing strategy proposed by Mayor Ed Gainey, and seemingly supported by the brass of the Pittsburgh Police, is to have more cops walking neighborhood beats. This is where Mr. Sherman’s Mercer County insight can be brought to the big city: Not every encounter with a police officer needs to be confrontational.

Especially in places where mutual distrust between police and the people runs high, confrontation can become habitual. The only way to break down that habit is with better habits — such as habits of generosity.

In suburban St. Paul, Mn., for instance, a mother and daughter recently donated thousands of dollars in fast food gift cards to local police departments. Cops can then distribute them to people they meet who need a meal. It wouldn’t be hard to find donors, or thoughtful local businesses, willing to do the same here.

It may not be prudent for Pittsburgh cops to distribute Smiley cookies in lieu of citations, but having some goodies on hand for random street interactions — that’s the kind of small act of kindness that develops into habits that can, over time, reform a culture, both of a neighborhood and of a police department.

Ultimately, the first rule of policing is the first rule of life: Treat others as you want to be treated. And everyone loves a treat.