After Russia invaded Ukraine, we argued that, “If infrastructure was the theme of the first year of the Biden administration, industrial policy should be the theme of the next.” On Tuesday, the president signed into law the bipartisan CHIPS and Science Act, which provides over $250 billion in investments and incentives to the American semiconductor industry. It has been called Washington’s most substantial piece of industrial policy in 50 years.
Major shocks to the international economy, from COVID-19 to the war in Ukraine, have proven that a laissez-faire attitude toward strategic resources and manufacturing leaves America vulnerable. The revelation in spring of 2020 that most of the prerequisites for American pharmaceuticals come from China, and the global supply chain troubles that are hampering American infrastructure improvements (including the Fern Hollow Bridge replacement), have made clear that the United States has sacrificed our security and independence to a self-destructive idea of globalism and free trade.
America’s once robust chip manufacturing industry is one of the worst victims. Three-quarters of all chip manufacturing capacity, and 100% of the capacity to make the most high-tech chips, is located in Asia. Most of that comes from the enormous Taiwanese foundries that the Chinese Communist Party is openly salivating over. These chips aren’t just for laptops and smartphones: They’re essential for everything from children’s toys to cars to medical equipment. America (and our allies) would be in grave trouble if the CCP gains control of these factories.
The CHIPS and Science Act recognizes these facts, and begins the process of correcting them. It allocates $52 billion in tax credits and subsidies to semiconductor chip manufacturers who commit to investing in domestic production of these essential products. Importantly, the law includes guardrails that ensure the money is spent for the national benefit, including prohibitions on expanding operations in “countries of concern,” which include China. The law further allocates $200 billion to research in key sectors that will keep America competitive with the rest of the world, like artificial intelligence and robotics.
For Pittsburgh, one particularly encouraging provision is the creation of 20 regional technology hubs, each specializing in an area of strategic research and manufacturing. Pittsburgh is well-positioned to be one of those hubs — and the presence of Carnegie Mellon University president Farnam Jahanian at the White House signing ceremony signals that state and federal officials know this. It will be up to the region’s public and private sector leaders to ensure southwest Pennsylvania gets its fair share of the funding.
The divvying up of federal favors drove some opposition to the bill. Pennsylvania’s retiring Republican senator, Pat Toomey, was not wrong that choosing winners among semiconductor manufacturers will distort the market. But the alternative is a global marketplace that cares nothing for American workers or national interests, and one in many cases dominated by an adversarial power.
The question isn’t whether the United States should embrace industrial policy in this new era of great power competition. It’s how it should embrace industrial policy. The CHIPS and Science Act is a promising start.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.