Pope Francis’ trip to Canada to apologize for the Catholic Church’s role in the abuse of Indigenous children is unprecedented. At issue now in Pope Francis’ gestures of repentance for the Church’s oversight of Canada’s residential schools is whether it is possible at all to apologize for historic crimes of a monstrous scale. Somehow, though, it must be. Without reconciliation, humanity is doomed to endless rounds of recrimination, resentment and revenge.
Currently, workers are searching school grounds for the graves of missing children, and stories of the sexual exploitation of children by church and school authorities continues to come to light. It is painful to acknowledge such a dark reality, but it is necessary, if repentance and forgiveness is to mean anything. The foundation for reconciliation must always be truth.
For those who experienced, directly or indirectly, the residential schools’ programs of forced assimilation, processing the pope’s apology will be, at best, difficult. No one can coerce people to forgive, and some will not.
The pontiff, however, is in a unique position as both a global religious and secular leader. His actions set an example for addressing historic sins; he has the authority and power to accompany an apology with actions that could help heal the harm inflicted on generations of indigenous people. Making amends, in both secular politics and Catholic teaching, is essential to repentance.
Pope Francis also understands the place of grace. When he was presented with a feathered headdress of honor, he accepted it — not in a spirit of triumph, but humility. Owing to the enormity of the crimes committed by representatives of the church, many Indigenous people took offense. That’s their right, but rejecting Pope Francis’ sincere apology would make healing practically impossible.
It’s not a question of whitewashing, which would violate the commitment to truth that genuine forgiveness demands, but of emerging from this dark place whole. It is in the interests of both the sinners and those who were sinned against to begin the long journey of reconciliation.
Pope Francis has shown that he takes his responsibility as a spiritual leader seriously. He has done all that he can do. It is now up to the afflicted to forgive, as far as they can, those who have trespassed against them. It’s a tortuous journey to grace we all, sooner or later, have to take.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.