Members of the Pittsburgh Board of Public Education had legitimate reasons to make the popular Wayne Walters the district’s permanent superintendent. But the move also has some risks the board and Mr. Walters should keep in mind in moving the city’s troubled public schools forward.

In retaining Mr. Walters, a 32-year veteran of the district and last year’s interim superintendent, the board missed a chance to bring in a fresh perspective at the top. In executing needed reforms, views from the outside are often the most insightful.

To make sure the district makes the changes students need, Mr. Walters ought to immediately seek capable deputies from outside the district’s bureaucracy. As PPS superintendent, Mr. Walters is on familiar turf, but three decades in the same insulated bureaucracy could blind him to institutional shortcomings, innovative solutions and personnel weaknesses.

That said, Mr. Walters handled his interim tenure capably. Even more encouraging is the enthusiasm with which the community — teachers union leaders, students, city officials, parents — have received his appointment. He starts the job with a level of community support and respect that no imported administrator — and few internal candidates — could garner.

Advertise with us

Mr. Walters understands that he is the face of the district. He responded quickly and compassionately to tragedies at Pittsburgh schools this year, most notably the January murder of Oliver Citywide Academy student Marquis Campbell. He’s already launched his “Fresh Start for the Head and Heart” program, which provides innovative academic support. There is a sense of optimism around the district that contrasts sharply with the tenure of disgraced superintendent Anthony Hamlet.

The new superintendent inherits a district still recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic; students have experienced learning losses and mental health problems. The district’s well-intentioned experiments in lax discipline have generally failed students and teachers. Mr. Walters will have to figure out how to preserve the best of progressive practices while maintaining stable and safe classrooms that allow students to learn without excessive disruptions.

He also faces tough but necessary decisions to shed buildings and land that no longer serve a diminishing number of students. The district can’t continue to squeeze property taxpayers with excess real-estate that doesn’t advance the core mission of education.

An urban school superintendent has one of the nation’s toughest jobs. To do it right, Mr. Walters must complement his three decades of experience in PPS, as both teacher and administrator, with new hires who can look at the district’s troubles with fresh eyes and see things he can’t. If he does, he may be able to fulfill the promise of reform and earn the confidence that the board and community have placed in him.