News from national real estate company Highwoods Properties that it will sell its marquee Downtown assets — PPG Place and the EQT Building — to fund projects in Dallas, Texas, should not squash the city’s office market. But it is clear, or should be, that Pittsburgh still struggles from the economic shocks of generations ago; it will not soon become a top growth market nationally.

And so what? There’s still plenty to cheer in Pittsburgh’s near-term future. Many parts of the city, most notably the Strip District and East Liberty, are seeing explosive growth. In the new Target, Downtown has a major retailer for the first time in several years. The city’s universities are expanding; their educational and economic impacts are growing.

The lingering hope that Pittsburgh would become the next Portland, Austin or even Columbus was never realistic, anyway. Explosive growth was much easier for these young cities — with their younger populations — than for an older industrial city with an established footprint.

Allegheny County’s declining population still poses a formidable challenge: More elderly people than young people means more deaths than births. Significant in-migration is needed to maintain population levels. That’s a legacy of the days when twice as many people were packed into Pittsburgh’s 55 square miles, and a headwind the region will battle for years.

Advertise with us

Complicating matters for any city, COVID-19 has transformed many people’s relationships with their cities. Remote work hasn’t just reduced the necessity to go into an office; it has also made moving to more rural locales a real option. The year 2019 may have been Downtown’s modern apogee, much the same as other cities’ urban cores.

Given these structural challenges, no one should be shocked that a profit-seeking corporation like Highwoods would shift focus to a metropolis with more dollars to vacuum. On that front, Pittsburgh can’t compete. But Pittsburgh shouldn’t strive to be Dallas.

The project of Pittsburgh isn’t to become a less genuine version of another city but to become the best Pittsburgh. That means figuring out how to improve and repurpose its historic assets, including land and water, buildings, and infrastructure.

The task facing regional leaders, public and private, is building an authentic Pittsburgh, not becoming a second-hand version of another city.