For more than a year, the Wolf Administration pursued a heavy-handed, ill-conceived plan to levy expensive tolls on nine bridges across the state to pay for their replacements. Legislators, local governments and the public pushed back, but the governor stubbornly pressed forward.

But now, Mr. Wolf and PennDOT have encountered a road block they can’t get around: Pennsylvania’s courts. On Thursday, the Commonwealth Court ruled the administration failed to follow the law when it developed the bridge toll plan and tried to force it on people, without giving them a chance to object.

So ends — we hope for good — one of the most misguided initiatives of Mr. Wolf’s tenure. The administration can appeal to the state Supreme Court, but we expect the plan would meet the same fate there.

The lawsuit, brought by Allegheny County municipalities Bridgeville, Collier and South Fayette, argued PennDOT circumvented the state’s public-private partnership (P3) law by seeking approval from the Public-Private Transportation Partnership Board for the general authority to toll bridges — not the right to toll particular bridges. As a result, affected municipalities were shut out. They couldn’t know if their bridges, such as the I-79 overpass above Route 50, were on the list.

Advertise with us

It was a battle not only between state and local governments, but also between the executive branch and legislature. After the plan was announced, the Senate transportation committee voted 9-4 to require legislative approval for any road projects that included tolling. They were right to do so: The executive branch should not be able to unilaterally tax commuters, travelers and the trucking industry. It’s up to legislators and the next governor to do that.

This should end efforts to replace bridges through targeted tolling in Pennsylvania. Both gubernatorial candidates — Democrat Josh Shapiro and Republican Doug Mastriano — oppose the plan. It doesn’t make sense for Mr. Wolf to restart the lengthy state approval process.

After the budget process wraps up — and the sooner the better — the Wolf administration and legislative leaders should start to talk about long-term, broad-based funding for the state’s roads and bridges. Bridge-tolling was always a bandage for a broken transportation system that needs a more serious fix from Harrisburg.