Just after 1 a.m. on Wednesday morning, Nicholas John Roske got out of a cab in front of Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home, intending to kill the justice and then himself, according to the affidavit included with the government’s criminal complaint. Fortunately, he saw two federal agents watching the house and walked away. He was caught only because he turned himself in, admitting on a 911 call that he’d come to Maryland to kill the justice.

Mr. Roske told federal agents that he was upset about the leaked Dobbs decision on abortion. The justice was also one of the majority in the Dobbs decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. Mr. Roske was also upset about the killings in Uvalde, Texas, and worried the Court will expand gun rights in an upcoming case. He’d decided “to give his life a purpose” by killing Mr. Kavanaugh.

Plans like Mr. Roske’s are the inevitable result of the feeling on the left and the right that the people who disagree with them are not just wrong, but the enemy, who wants to impose on the nation morally repulsive laws and culture. The other side is a “danger to democracy” or a “danger to American values,” or one of a hundred other such charges.

This attitude removes the work of the government from the give and take of politics to something more like war. Not surprisingly, less stable people will see it as real war and choose their targets based on their political convictions.

Advertise with us

Fortunately, so far, very few have done this. But even a few undermine the security upon which a democratic system depends. Our public servants must feel safe in exercising their duties. They must feel their families are safe. If the cost of public service is a risk of someone killing you or your spouse or your children, fewer people will take up public service. The ones who are willing to risk the danger will often be the more ambitious and the less qualified.

Judges are particularly vulnerable, both due to the high stakes of their work and their relatively weak security. The U.S. Marshalls are ostensibly tasked with protecting federal judges, but lack the resources to do so effectively.

Meanwhile, we don’t have much hope that the major political actors in politics and the media will treat their opponents with more respect and moderate their language. They’re too polarized for that, and the language is too valuable a political tool. If you have a choice to run against a Mr. Rogers you disagree with or the devil himself, you’ll run against the devil.

We shouldn’t underestimate how exposed our public servants are. As the affidavit reports, Mr. Roske “decided that he would kill the Supreme Court Justice after finding the Justice’s Montgomery County address on the internet.”