Last October, we said several properties owned by the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh were so poorly maintained they “barely qualified as ‘indoors.’” According to a new Post-Gazette investigation, the same can be said of many privately-owned rental properties.
Neena Hagen and Jack Troy’s report found that in recent years, city inspectors found 730 properties to be “unfit for human habitation.” That includes dozens of properties each in Homewood, Carrick and student-rental-dense South Oakland. Spongy floors; rampant vermin; collapsing ceilings: If you can imagine it, landlords in Pittsburgh have tolerated it.
But that’s not the worst part of the story. Because rental inspections are currently sporadic, many more buildings are just as derelict as the ones inspectors have visited. Because the city has no central registry of rental properties, we can’t know how many of these unsafe homes are being leased to desperate renters.
Pittsburgh City Council has tried twice before to create a rental property registry with regular inspections, in 2007 and 2015. Every time they are stymied by a single Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas judge, Joseph James. He insists that the fees imposed to maintain the registry and inspection program amount to an impermissible tax that, under Pittsburgh’s home rule charter, city council can’t impose.
The new system passed by council last November responds to this argument by setting the fees at the rates the City Clerk determines to be the true costs for services. These are figures that apply across the board to city services, and not just to the rental registry. To declare them a “tax” would be to impugn the clerk’s office, not to mention the city’s entire fee system.
Under this scheme, an owner of 20 units would pay as little as about $300 every three to five years for application, inspection and inspectors’ travel. Meanwhile, Allentown, Pa., charges an annual $75 per unit fee, while Philadelphia charges $56 and Erie $40. Pittsburgh’s plan is a bargain.
The fees are minimal inconveniences for landlords — who will mostly just pass the cost along to renters — and will fund a program needed to enhance public safety and public health. Again Judge James postponed the ordinance. Is there a rental registry program that will pass the judge’s muster?
Why does the judge have the chance to stop the city from charging its reasonable fees? Because landlords associations always file suit against them. Good owners should want a way to distinguish their properties from those owned by negligent landlords. Instead, they keep rejecting an opportunity to show common cause with the public against derelict and dangerous housing.
The rental registry is good policy, and city council has created a program within the bounds of the Home Rule Charter. Judge Joseph James should allow it to stand.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.