Mayview. Marcy. Dixmont. SCI-Fayette. SCI-Greene. SCI-Somerset. The first three are state psychiatric hospitals that have closed in the Pittsburgh region over the past 40 years. The second three are state prisons that have opened here in that same time.

Many people who genuinely need residential or other intensive mental health care, for their own good and the safety of the community, end up on the streets or in prison. And sometimes they end up in prison after committing terribly heinous crimes. Even though only a small minority of people with psychiatric challenges endanger others, the treatment of the mentally ill is both a public health and a public safety issue.

There is not, of course, a one-to-one correlation between patients at the old state hospitals and inmates in the new state prisons. Many people who would have been institutionalized in the old mental health regime thrive, whether in community-based care settings, or under the periodic care of a psychiatrist, or as perfectly normal people who would’ve been treated as mad in past generations.

This was the vision of the Community Mental Health Act of 1963, which ultimately led to a 90% drop in the number of psychiatric beds in state hospitals. Unfortunately, states were thrilled to close their expensive psychiatric institutions, but many of the community-based facilities proposed to replace them were left unfunded and unbuilt.

Advertise with us

This doesn’t mean resurrecting Dixmont and Marcy and Mayview, which in many respects were houses of horror to rival, and maybe even surpass, modern prisons. But it does mean recognizing that some people will hurt themselves and others if they are not compelled to undergo treatment for their psychiatric disorders. But even as awareness of the importance of mental health care continues to rise, the resources the country dedicates to it are woefully, dangerously insufficient.

One way Pennsylvania tried to strike the balance between community safety and individual rights was to lower the standard for receiving involuntary assisted outpatient therapy (AOT). This involves home visits from mental health professionals and avoids a full in-patient commitment. The 2018 law says that counties only need to show “clear and convincing evidence that the person would benefit” from AOT, not that he or she is a “clear and present danger.”

However, every one of the 48 counties in Pennsylvania with mental health agencies has opted out of the AOT law. Cost seems to be the biggest barrier. As budget season continues in Harrisburg, legislators should look for ways to fund robust AOT programs that could intervene earlier in mental health crises.

This is a small step toward what needs to be a larger overhaul of mental healthcare in Pennsylvania and across the nation. A serious response to the stupefying violence being inflicted on the innocent will consider both the weapons used, and the people who use them.