Pittsburgh City Council is ramping up to take on the city’s large and cash-flush nonprofit community — again.

It’s a righteous cause, but one that needs an empathetic understanding of the viewpoints and interests of UPMC, Highmark/AHN, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and others.

The latest effort to tax the nonprofits, however, got off to an awkward start, with Councilman Ricky Burgess, who’s leading the charge, working from a dusty playbook.

In 2009, Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl proposed a 1% tax on tuitions paid to colleges and universities in the city. That first-of-its-kind bid made national news.

Advertise with us

But the schools screamed bloody murder. Mr. Ravenstahl dropped the proposal when the city secured a vague commitment from its largest nonprofits to increase the payments in lieu of taxes (PILOT) they made from 2005 to 2007.

Obviously, this wasn’t a long-term solution.

Mr. Burgess’ proposed 1% levy on educational and medical services echoes the Ravenstahl approach. It was the opening salvo, perhaps meant to push the nonprofits to the negotiating table. This time, however, the nonprofits knew where all of this was headed, and they didn’t intend to cower.

Mr. Burgess’s next move, however, holds more promise. He’d like council to direct city finance officials to “determine the true market value of property owned or held” by the schools, medical centers and other nonprofits that operate within city limits. Market value will let council, the mayor and the public know how much these institutions would pay in property tax, if they were taxed like everyone else. Some percent of that figure will serve as a baseline for PILOT negotiations.

Mr. Burgess’s proposal authorizes both city council and the mayor to undertake those negotiations. Council naturally doesn’t want to lock itself out of the process, but nominating one or the other — ideally, the chief executive — would be more efficient and effective.

Advertise with us

In an interview with the Post-Gazette deputy editorial page editor Brandon McGinley at the start of Mr. Gainey’s term, the mayor vowed “to sit down and talk to [the nonprofits] about how we work together.” That promise was vague, at best, but Mr. Gainey has, since then, shown a talent for getting things done. He deserves a crack at this nut, as well.

As for the nonprofits, their reluctance to fork over PILOT cash doesn’t stem entirely from self-interest. They are members of a community of large tax-exempt organizations. If they roll over, they’ll set a bad precedent for their peers.

Mr. Gainey, council and the public need reasonable expectations. PILOT programs rarely generate the revenue hoped for, but they are still good policy. With the support of city council members, pragmatic negotiations between Mr. Gainey and the nonprofits should achieve a fair and lasting solution.