Pittsburgh’s City Council is on a roll.
After an outrageous attempt by council members to raise their pay by 22%, Councilman Ricky Burgess further embarrassed this esteemed body by opposing a common-sense bill to make public the condition of city-owned infrastructure.
Now, Mr. Burgess is trying to outdo himself by proposing a 1% tax on the use of medical and higher education institutions in Pittsburgh. The estimated $50 million a year in revenue would flow into a dedicated infrastructure fund. Council will discuss this proposed tax on college students and sick people at Wednesday’s council meeting.
They should kill the plan there and then.
Mr. Burgess framed his bill, introduced Tuesday, as a way to initiate a dialogue with some of Pittsburgh’s largest nonprofits, which receive vast tax discounts due to their 501(c)(3) status.
That discussion does, indeed, need to take place. We recently pointed out the incongruity of UPMC bringing in a whopping $1.46 billion in (non)profit during the previous year, and argued that for such organizations to earn what amount to public subsidies, they must serve a higher public purpose. Institutions of higher learning have endowments of hundreds of millions, or even billions, of dollars and often earn surpluses as well. Carnegie Mellon University, for example, reported its net assets increasing nearly $200 million in 2020 — during the pandemic.
And yet, Mr. Burgess’ proposal is to tax the consumers of education and health care rather than the organizations themselves.
It must be said, many of the city’s nonprofits operate in good faith; until 2013, some even made payments in lieu of taxes to the city even though they weren’t obligated to do so. Still, in the quest to balance nonprofits’ responsibility to the city with the city’s need to address infrastructure, passing that burden on to students and patients should have been the last resort, not the first.
True, many students and patients have the means to cover such a tax; moreover, they use the infrastructure that the revenue would go toward maintaining. Mr. Burgess rightly pointed out that a 1% tax would be unlikely to deter people from attending school or seeking medical care in the city.
But the premise of the tax remains fundamentally flawed. It sidesteps the root question of whether the duties of a nonprofit need adjustment by taxing their customers — many of whom already pay income and other taxes in the city. And it does this rather than attempt to extract compensation for those public services that nonprofits use.
Mr. Burgess is right to call for such a conversation, but his plan suggests council isn’t serious about asking these institutions to assist the city.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.