The early response of government officials at all levels — city, state, federal — to the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse has been vigorous and reassuring.
But it will be essential, going forward, that all these levels of government be straightforward about the failures — not just structural, but political and bureaucratic — that led to the near-tragedy.
The state can start by releasing the details of the Fern Hollow Bridge’s inspections, at least back to the first “poor” ratings in 2011. The state was concerned enough about the bridge that it mandated annual, as opposed to biannual, inspections as far back as 2014 — but only odd-year summary reports are available online. Where are the rest? And no details of these reports, beyond the basic scores, have been made public.
The September 2021 inspection report, conducted by private contractor Gannett Fleming, is of particular interest. How does a bridge collapse only four months after an inspection finds it fundamentally safe? Is PennDOT effectively overseeing its contactors?
PennDOT argues that federal law bans the release of detailed inspection reports because malefactors could use them to target a structure’s weaknesses, but that’s hardly relevant now that the bridge has collapsed. The public deserves to know what the city and state knew about the integrity of this public thoroughfare.
The early movement toward fixing the problem has been better. Mayor Ed Gainey and Gov. Tom Wolf both quickly declared emergencies, which will cut through some of the typical red tape that snarls major projects. Mr. Gainey also moved decisively to name Darryl Jones, the city’s experienced and highly competent fire chief, to the position of emergency management coordinator.
As for the legislative side of city government, on Tuesday — only four days after the collapse — Councilman Corey O’Connor coordinated with Mr. Gainey’s office to introduce two bills to provide better oversight over the city’s aging infrastructure. The first would create a 15-member infrastructure commission to keep tabs on city assets and advise council about priorities; the second would require the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure to produce regular public reports on the state of Pittsburgh’s bridges, tunnels and so on.
These are smart proposals that council ought to approve quickly. It shouldn’t have taken a disaster to scare up these ideas, but the city is still responding with encouraging speed.
Lastly, the near-immediate promise of $25.3 million from the federal government for bridge reconstruction resolved the most pressing question of replacement: How do we pay for it? In fact, city and state officials think this is almost certainly more than what’s necessary — but that’s where the new infrastructure commission will be useful: to prioritize spending the leftovers.
All this good news, however, mustn’t distract the public from demanding transparency and accountability regarding the causes of the collapse. Honesty and straightforwardness about how this happened will only bolster public confidence in the response.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.