In Penn Hills last weekend, 66 people lost their homes in a fire that didn’t have to be as destructive as it was. The response from the fire department was hampered, according to Penn Hills Fire Station 227 Chief Bill Jeffcoat, by the building’s improperly functioning alarm system. Worse, it had been known to be faulty for at least a year.
“Any fire alarms that we’ve had there, we have not been notified by the alarm company,” Chief Jeffcoat told Post-Gazette reporter Jesse Bunch. Instead, tenants had to call 911 to alert the first responders, wasting precious time.
The chief blamed a dispute between the fire department and the municipal code enforcement department for the problem. Whoever is to blame, this kind of slippage is unacceptable in matters of life and death. Small lapses in fire preparedness — and a faulty alarm isn’t exactly small — can make all the difference between a minor emergency and a massive tragedy.
Whatever slippage occurred between the fire and code enforcement departments in Penn Hills needs to be investigated and corrected immediately. What happened should be made public, as should the solution. People need to know the problem that aggravated this fire has been fixed. And Pittsburgh, which has hundreds of aging apartment buildings, should audit its procedures and ensure its enforcement division is properly staffed and funded.
We were blessed no one was killed or injured; next time, we might not be as fortunate.
Safe apartment buildings start with landlords. In choosing to rent housing to tenants, a landlord takes on an enormous responsibility, one that is too often shirked in order to save costs, or simply due to incompetence.
Read More
But the public authority has an essential role in making sure landlords maintain safe housing. This problem, like most problems, hits hardest the poor, who are most likely to live in substandard housing with fire hazards.
That’s certainly one of the lessons from the Philadelphia and New York disasters.
The Jan. 5 blaze in Philly, where four adults and eight children died, appears to have begun with a kindergartener playing with a lighter. But unsafe fire play became catastrophic, partly because the apartment building had no fire extinguishers, and most, if not all, of the smoke detectors were not functioning.
Four days later in the Bronx, eight more children were killed, alongside nine adults, in a fire caused by a faulty space heater. Again, problems in the building itself made matters far worse: A malfunctioning fire door caused a surge of heat and smoke through the corridors, overcoming tenants who should have been able to escape.
Fire is a primal force. We will never be immune to it. But with a little preparation, we can minimize the risk it poses to lives and livelihoods. Fire safety violations need to be detected and punished, quickly and strictly. We will never know how many lives depend on it — until one day, horribly, we do.
Clarification: A Jan. 26, Post-Gazette editorial, “Penn Hills blaze shows need for fire safety review,” should have stated Penn Hills Fire Station 227, Fire Marshal Chuck Miller, and the municipal code enforcement department have worked together to get the owner of Rodi Arms Apartments to fix long-standing problems with the fire alarm system. Thirty families lost their homes in Saturday’s fire. “We all work together with one goal -- safety,” Fire Chief Bill Jeffcoat said, adding the Penn Hills fire marshal also directs local code enforcement.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.