Retired FBI agent Vince Pankoke of Richland Township in Cambria County has worked on cold cases before, but his latest was so cold he told “60 Minutes” it was “frozen in ice.”
Mr. Pankoke, who retired to Florida after working some of the biggest cases in the FBI’s portfolio, was contacted by an unlikely patron to apply his acumen to a case that is seven decades old.
He was asked to lead a special investigative unit in Amsterdam that had one mission: comb over long-dead leads and find new clues to the identity of person who betrayed 15-year-old Anne Frank and her family to the Nazis in 1944.
Anne Frank, as every middle school student knows, is the author of the most famous first-person chronicle of the Holocaust. “The Diary of Anne Frank” relates her family’s two-year ordeal hiding in the crawl space and secret attic annex of a sympathetic Dutch family.
When the Frank family was discovered, they were sent to separate concentration camps where they all were killed by the Nazi regime — with the exception of Otto Frank, the family patriarch, who miraculously survived Auschwitz. After the war, Otto Frank recovered his daughter’s diary and eventually published it. It has never gone out of print.
For millions of readers who have been deeply moved by “The Diary of Anne Frank,” one overriding question has loomed over all others — Who was responsible for sending that beautiful girl who spilled her humanity over every page to the death camps?
That whodunnit has occupied professional and amateur sleuths for decades, but the list of likely suspects has remained short. That’s where Mr. Pankoke comes in.
Mr. Pankoke and his team of 20 historians, data specialists, criminologists and code breakers used AI and cutting edge technology to re-canvas the scene. They pulled up every scrap of information about the case.
Fortunately they also had the use of Mr. Pankoke’s powerful, intuitive insight. They stumbled upon a letter that had been in Otto Frank’s possession that implicated a Jewish notary named Arnold van den Bergh as the culprit.
Mr. Van den Bergh was a member of the Jewish Council, a group of Dutch Jewish collaborators who helped the Germans locate Jews in exchange for their families not being harassed or killed.
After eliminating possible alibis, Mr. Pankoke settled on the notary as the most likely culprit. It was circumstantial evidence but still compelling.
Because the suspect is also Jewish, Otto Frank may have ignored the clue in the 1950s because it was too painful to consider the possibility that another Jewish man was responsible.
Mr. Pankoke told “60 Minutes” that although he would stake his professional reputation on the fact that Mr. Van den Bergh is guilty, the lack of a direct confession or eye witness would’ve hurt the prosecution in any American court. Some historians, also, have said that the evidence still isn’t strong enough to make a confident accusation.
Even though Mr. Pankoke didn’t find his smoking gun, he’s confident he found a pretty warm one. For now, the case of who betrayed Anne Frank feels as if it has been (mostly) solved.
But the greatest mystery of all — the mystery of the astounding evil into which individuals and entire societies can descend — remains with us and will for the rest of human history, however long that might be.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.