Jim Rogers’ death was unnecessary and, thus, tragic. And a needless death at the hands of people who should protect us is especially tragic.

The community and Mr. Rogers’ family need, and deserve, to know what happened. Justice and the Police Bureau’s credibility demand answers.

Here’s some of what we know so far:

On the morning of Wednesday, Oct. 13, Mr. Rogers, then homeless, found a discarded bike on the sidewalk, along Harriet Street in Bloomfield. Someone apparently wanted to give the bike away, and he took it for a spin. That triggered a call to the police.

Advertise with us

Almost 24 hours later, the 51-year-old Black man was dead at UPMC Mercy hospital after multiple zaps with a Taser. He was transported in a squad car instead of an ambulance. One could question how much urgency officers felt in trying to save him or even in treating him with minimal dignity.

Given the intense public interest and institutional importance of this case, the investigation has been frustratingly slow. The public and the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office are still waiting for the county medical examiner’s report.

It took the Bureau of Police more than two months to announce disciplinary action against nine officers. More troubling, details about the incident and the discipline, including the officers’ names, came to light only because of an illicit leak of a Critical Incident Review Board document.

On a more hopeful note, reports about the comprehensive nature of the internal document suggest the bureau is willing to examine itself openly and honestly. That so many officers failed Mr. Rogers is appalling; that the bureau diligently uncovered those failures is encouraging.

Tasers themselves are not necessarily the problem. They are meant to be non-lethal alternatives to firearms. But officers must know how and when to use them.

Advertise with us

We support the bureau’s recommended reforms, including calling EMS personnel to the scene of every Taser deployment and requiring a supervisor to medically assess every use-of-force incident. It’s surprising these policies were not already in place.

Real accountability, however, can’t happen without transparency. On that front, the bureau fell short.

It should not have taken a leak for details of the bureau’s report to come to light. The public’s knowledge of this information will not undermine the county’s ongoing investigation. Concealing it will only arouse suspicions that may be entirely unwarranted. The people can’t assess, or influence, how the bureau fixes the problem without knowing where it failed and who was responsible.

If the mayor and DA really believe a systemic failure led to Mr. Rogers’ tragic and needless death, they should be pressing for transparency, not whining about leaks.

The public must know how, and why, Jim Rogers died.