The off-hand tweets of Tony Award-winning actress Bette Midler don’t represent cultural or political barometers. Nevertheless, her zinger on West Virginia last week conveyed some of the stereotypes Fox News commentators and some Republicans attribute to Democratic-leaning East Coast elites.

Taking aim at U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, who torpedoed, at least for the moment, the Build Back Better plan, Ms. Midler called West Virginia “poor, illiterate and strung out.”

Not a nice thing to say, especially if “strung out” refers to the high rates of opioid addiction that have brought horrific suffering to Appalachia.

Ms. Midler quickly apologized for the tweet, but the cultural arrogance behind it might represent a bigger problem than Mr. Manchin for Democrats in the midterm elections.

Advertise with us

With former President Donald Trump getting nearly 70 percent of West Virginia’s vote in 2020, it’s easy to forget West Virginia was once one of the country’s most reliably Democratic states. Its hardscrabble rural population made a natural constituency for the political party that wanted to wage war on poverty.

Appalachia benefited enormously from the New Deal. For decades, West Virginians supported even such landslide losers as Adlai Stevenson, Michael Dukakis and even Jimmy Carter, who was creamed by Ronald Reagan in 1980. That allegiance to the Democratic Party lasted through Bill Clinton’s two terms, but then it rapidly and dramatically shifted.

Culture explains part of that shift. Those who worked with their hands in Appalachia increasingly began to feel today’s Democrats had no interest in them or their concerns. Nor did they share their vision of America.

West Virginia is overwhelmingly white and poor. Only Mississippi has a lower median household income, and more than half all West Virginia adults have only a high school education — or less.

In West Virginia and elsewhere, the modern Democratic Party has lost many working-class, blue-collar white voters, who were a key part of the coalition that once helped Democrats dominate the nation. A look at rural Pennsylvania or Ohio shows the same pattern. (Republicans have image problems, too. Suburban places like once-reliably Republican Bucks County are a large part of the reason Joe Biden won Pennsylvania last year.)

Advertise with us

Consider: Al Gore lost West Virginia narrowly in 2000; had he won it, he would have been president.

Twelve years later, Mitt Romney carried every county in the state, a feat Trump repeated — twice. Joe Manchin is now the only Democrat representing the state in Congress, or in any statewide office.

Poor, illiterate, strung out.

With midterm elections looming, Democrats looking to win should ponder what happened to their party in West Virginia.