When family and friends gather and hunt for a place to eat, it’s natural to wonder at which area restaurants other diners had favorable experiences.

Enter Google reviews, the blessing and — in the case of one Pittsburgh staple in need of some local love — bane of the hospitality industry. Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room, a delightfully rustic wood-fired pizza joint in Downtown, is the victim of a case of mistaken identity.

A different restaurant in Bentonville, Ark. called Oven and Tap behaved unpalatably regarding a hefty $4,400 tip left by a large party for servers, ultimately firing the server who was to have received the tip.

That story captured the nation’s imagination, and many do-gooder citizens took it upon themselves to leave nasty reviews on the restaurant’s Google page to punish the owners for their holiday misdeeds.

Advertise with us

These well-intentioned keyboard warriors’ aim wasn’t precise, and the similarly named Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room has caught some unfriendly fire, knocking down its star rating and distressing the owners considerably.

The comments attached to these reviews make it clear they were meant to be pointed at Oven and Tap.

Proper is a welcome addition to the Cultural District, a warm and inviting place to grab a bite of Italian and socialize before or after shows. Google should be more responsive in removing misdirected reviews, and local Yinzers who’ve stopped by the joint should mount a counter-offensive campaign to boost the place’s star rating back to where it belongs.

Before the kerfuffle, it had a rating of about a 4.6 out of 5 with more than 1,000 positive mentions, according to the Post-Gazette’s Dan Gigler.

A similar situation occurred on the review site Yelp, but that site has already corrected the error.

Advertise with us

“Probably at least half the people that come in say they saw our reviews on Yelp or on Google. Particularly people from out of town,” owner Suzanne Hrach told the Post-Gazette. “It matters.”

Indeed it does, particularly during a busy holiday season. Ms. Hrach is responding to each comment, politely explaining the situation.

In the meantime, let’s show this plucky hometown spot some affection.