Pittsburgh City Council is considering following the lead of Philadelphia and the state of Virginia by banning traffic stops for secondary offenses, such as expired tags and burned out headlights. Contrary to the proposal’s critics, we think this change will make the city safer, not more dangerous.

Consider two tragedies.

On the night of Aug. 7, 2021, Chicago Police officer Ella French pulled over a sedan driven by 22-year-old Eric Morgan for an expired registration. During the ensuing confrontation, Morgan’s 21-year-old brother, Emonte, fatally shot Officer French and wounded her partner.

On June 24, 2017, a police officer in Kent, Wash., pulled over 20-year-old Giovann Joseph-McDade for a canceled registration. The young man sped away and another officer fired his gun, fatally wounding him.

Advertise with us

When a police officer makes a traffic stop, the range of possible outcomes is immense. Sometimes it ends with a smile and a warning. Sometimes it ends with bloodshed.

According to a New York Times report, around the country, 10 officers had been killed during traffic stops from January through October of this year. The Times also reports that 400 unarmed drivers and passengers who were not being pursued due to a violent crime have been killed by police since Sept. 30, 2016.

Traffic stops are a high-stress, high-adrenaline moment for everyone involved. This is especially true for Black motorists, who are pulled over at disproportionately high rates, especially for minor, or secondary, offenses. The heart races. The mind spools through the possible outcomes. In all likelihood, everything will be all right. But what if it isn’t? What if I flinch? What if I panic? What if he panics? What if it all goes wrong?

Reducing the number of these high-stakes interactions for low-stakes offenses isn’t about wokeness or lenience or indifference to the law; rather, it’s a common sense and low-risk way to improve the relationship between the police and those whom they serve.

First of all, this would not repeal vehicle safety and registration laws; warnings and citations would just be delivered by mail instead of face to face. And if you think that cars with out of date inspections pose an imminent threat to the public, you shouldn’t set foot in Maryland, Ohio, California, Florida or any of the dozens of other states with no regular safety inspections at all.

Advertise with us

Further, the new rule won’t stop police from pulling over drivers whom they have good cause to suspect of a more serious crime. What it will eliminate are easily abused “pretextual” stops, in which cops use the secondary offense as an excuse to snoop around a car they deem “suspicious” without having a legally legitimate cause.

This isn’t the first step toward ignoring vandalism or shoplifting, as some cities have done out of a false sense of justice. Nor is it the first step toward defunding the police. In fact, it should liberate city police to focus on more important work — like Mayor-elect Ed Gainey’s community policing initiative — rather than risking a violent confrontation to cite a teenager for a busted bumper.

No one, police or civilian, should be in a life-or-death situation because of paperwork. Ending traffic stops for secondary offenses is a practical move to improve public safety.