A popular mantra goes like this: “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme.” This may just be a clever way of conceding that history can — and does — repeat itself, though it is bound to look somewhat different each time.

This is to be expected. Sometimes lessons that were learned on battlefields five or six generations ago can be forgotten or obscured by the face-saving mythologies that creep in to swallow it whole. Consequently, having to repeat lessons now forgotten can be disastrous.

Recently, an esteemed documentary filmmaker and a popular presidential historian have both made comparisons between the politically fraught era before the Civil War and the irrationality and contentiousness of American politics today.

Instead of slavery or state’s rights instigating regional conflicts, it is mask mandates, vaccinations and suspicion about the integrity of our elections that have become the flashpoints of American politics.

Advertise with us

Filmmaker Ken Burns, whose documentaries about the American experience have become an integral part of PBS programming as well as an educator for much of America, said on a podcast recently that the present crisis is equal to three previous crises that shook the country profoundly: the Civil War, the Depression and World War II. “We’re looking down the muzzle of that gun,” Mr. Burns said.

Recently, presidential historian Jon Meacham pointed to the political fragmentation of the last four years as an indicator that we’re becoming a country where a huge chunk of citizens “would rather put their faith in an authoritarian rather than the Constitution.”

Mr. Meacham talked about the similarities between the 1850s and these times, but stopped short of predicting it would end in an armed conflict. He argued that our form of government is difficult to maintain because “democracies are about seeing each other not as rivals, but as neighbors. We do not see each other as neighbors in America at this hour.”

Neither Mr. Burns or Mr. Meacham pointed to the Jan. 6 storming of the Capitol by pro-Trump supporters as a Fort Sumter moment — the day the Confederate army fired the first shot of the Civil War on April 12, 1861 — but their pessimism about our future as a democracy comes through clearly in their respective takes of the present danger. Mr. Meacham went so far as to say our democracy is “hanging by a thread.”

When such perceptive observers of our politics — both past and present — see the kind of menacing clouds on the horizon that once precipitated a cataclysm that took nearly 700,000 lives, it would be wise for us all to listen. We should remember the lessons of the past and tremble at its echoes.