Satire isn’t dangerous unless you satirize Islam. This has been proved repeatedly in the 21st century. In 2005, a Danish newspaper published satirical drawings of the Prophet Muhammad, which led to violent protests around the world.
In an effort to denounce the climate of self-censorship surrounding Islam, and to stand in free speech solidarity with the Danish publication, the French satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo republished the cartoons the following year.
As a result, al-Qaida put a price on the head of Charlie Hebdo’s editor, Stéphane Charbonnier, better known as Charb, and the magazine’s offices were firebombed in 2011. The editorial board, however, remained steadfast in its commitment to free expression and published another drawing of the Prophet one year later. In 2015, three jihadists took Islamic blasphemy laws into their own hands and murdered 17 people at the offices of Charlie Hebdo and at a Jewish supermarket before being killed by police.
The trial for the 14 alleged accomplices of the attacks — accused of providing weapons and logistical support — began in Paris on Sept. 2. The legal proceedings, as one of the prosecutors put it, will be a “democratic answer to a barbaric act.” Naturally, Charlie Hebdo, which is still operating out of a secret location and still regularly receiving violent threats, republished the cartoons in the days leading up to the trial.
In treating Islam the way satirists treat every other religion, the French cartoonists showed Muslims that they were part of French democracy, and that their belief system would receive the same savage treatment as any other. The newspaper insulted everybody and laughed at everything, demonstrating that there is nothing we cannot talk about or satirize. They penned their barbs at rabbis, vicars and mullahs alike, exercising their inviolable right to criticize dogmas of any stripe.
To highlight the danger of self-censorship and the absurd reach of political correctness, Charlie Hebdo published a “responsible” issue of their paper, one that was sure not to hurt anyone’s feelings anywhere in the world. Each page therefore was left blank.
Charb and his fellow cartoonists demonstrated just how dangerous it is to stand for freedom. They challenged radical Islam and reminded free societies everywhere that there cannot be one set of beliefs that is protected above all others from criticism, and that Islam will not be given a “safe space” in Western cultures.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.