Nearly five years ago, Miladis Salgado, a 54-year-old Colombian immigrant living in Miami, returned home from work to discover that police had raided her home and seized her entire life savings — $15,000 in cash that she was saving for her daughter’s quinceañera, a 15th birthday celebration important in Latin American culture. The police conducted the operation based on a tip that Ms. Salgado’s estranged husband was dealing drugs.

Though that tip proved to be unfounded, the Drug Enforcement Agency used civil asset forfeiture, a legal process that allows law enforcement to seize money or property from an individual without criminal charges, in an attempt to keep the money.

Ms. Salgado rightly pursued the matter in court, using an attorney hired on contingency to fight the federal government for more than two years. But before the court could rule on the case, the DEA admitted there was no evidence of a crime and returned Ms. Salgado’s $15,000. But by handing the money over before a judgment was levied, the agency avoided having to reimburse her attorneys’ fees.

Ultimately left with just $10,000 of the $15,000 that was stolen from her by the government, Ms. Salgado has taken her righteous anger all the way to the Supreme Court, which is considering her argument that the DEA owes her $5,000 in legal fees.

Advertise with us

Civil asset forfeiture has rightly become a subject of significant controversy in recent years. The nonprofit Institute for Justice, which has helped people like Ms. Salgado and Rebecca Brown, who had more than $82,000 taken from her at Pittsburgh International Airport in August, challenged the government seizures, and has drawn a great deal of attention to the issue.

But Ms. Salgado’s case illustrates how legal loopholes allow the federal government to evade meaningful responsibility or accountability after unjustly seizing the property of innocent people.

Civil asset forfeiture is a gross misuse of government power and should be put to an end. But the Supreme Court should also help people like Ms. Salgado receive total reimbursement after being victimized by this unjust practice. Ms. Salgado should not be down $5,000 for standing up for her rights. The court should right this wrong.