The proposed Pittsburgh City Council ordinance that would ban city employees and elected officials from engaging in “hateful activities” not only raises concerns about defining such activities, but threatens to stifle free speech and debate.
The proposal was sent to the city Law Department for review, but this is one piece of legislation that council should reject.
Councilman Ricky Burgess’ proposal would amend the city’s Code of Conduct to prohibit employees and public officials from engaging in hateful activities toward other employees and officials “in person or in writing and/or across various media platforms” including email, Facebook and Twitter.
It defines hateful activities as those that “incite or engage in violence, intimidation, harassment, threats or defamation” targeting an individual or group based on 10 protected categories, including race, gender and sexual orientation.
The city’s Ethics Hearing Board would determine if alleged violations merit a fine or disciplinary action.
The ordinance is open to far too many interpretations of what constitutes a hateful activity. Could someone’s opposition or dissent on an ordinance, if expressed in person to someone who later blasts a supporter of the bill on social media, be considered inciting intimidation? Could mere opposition be enough to be classified as inciting harassment?
More to the point, is this type of legislation necessary? Federal laws provide protection against hate crimes. The city code already grants the Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations the power to investigate “any conditions having an adverse effect on intergroup relations in the city.”
Rev. Burgess said the ordinance is meant to reduce racism in Pittsburgh with City Council taking a lead role. “There is a difference between a hate crime and hateful activities ... This is not a crime, this is a morally reprehensible act …” he said.
Still, it’s no coincidence that the proposal comes mere weeks after a particularly contentious election for City Council president in which Rev. Burgess failed to secure a majority. He said that during elections he has been subjected to “vicious, hateful campaigns.”
Council President Theresa Kail-Smith, who took the office as a compromise candidate, acknowledged that the election process was “hurtful” with things being said or shared about her colleagues, although she offered no details.
Rev. Burgess’ goal of reducing racism in the city is laudable and worthy of ongoing council attention, but attempting to legislate “hateful activities” is not the means for doing so.
The answer to speech that one might disagree with or find reprehensible is more speech, more opinions, more debate, not less.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.