Is your memory as reliable as your political leanings?
A recent study at Ohio State University suggests that we tend to remember facts better when they fit our beliefs and reverse them when they do not.
In the study, led by assistant communications professor Jason Coronel, participants who were given accurate statistics about an issue not only confused numbers that contradicted their beliefs but, in a separate and related study, skewed them even further when sharing the data.
“People can self-generate their own misinformation. It doesn’t all come from external sources,” Mr. Coronel said, a warning to us all regarding our ability to self-delude when confronting numbers that undermine our points of view.
In the first study, 110 participants were presented with short written descriptions of four societal issues that included numerical information.
In pre-tests, the researchers found that when thenumbers fit with many of the participants’ understanding of the issue, such as most expecting more Americans to support same-sex marriage than oppose it, they remembered the numbers correctly when asked later about them.
On other issues, such as whether the number of Mexican immigrants in the United States rose or fell between 2007 and 2014, participants believed an increase had occurred and made the numbers match that belief. The number of Mexican immigrants declined from 12.8 million in 2007 to 11.7 million in 2014.
“We had instances where participants got the numbers exactly correct — 11.7 and 12.8 — but they would flip them around,” Mr. Coronel said, “They weren’t guessing — they got the numbers right, but their biases were leading them to misremember the direction they were going.”
And it wasn’t that they weren’t paying attention, according to eye-tracking the researchers conducted as part of the study. They actually looked back and forth when presented with surprising information.
“You would think that if they were paying more attention to the numbers that went against their expectations, they would have a better memory for them. But that’s not what we found,” Mr. Coronel said.
This study is a good reminder to check our facts before engaging on an issue. And the second OSU study offers even better reason to do so, and to be skeptical of what our like-minded friends tell us about the facts of a controversial subject.
The researchers designed the second study as a game of “telephone.”
The first person in the chain reviewed accurate statistics about the downward trend of Mexican immigrants living in the United States. Later he or she was asked to write down the numbers from memory. That person passed them along to a second person, who then had to write them down from memory, and so on.
The results showed that, on average, the first person flipped the numbers, saying that the number of Mexican immigrants increased by 900,000 from 2007 to 2014, rather than reporting the actual decrease of about 1.1 million.
By the end of the chain, the growth reported averaged 4.6 million.
Mr. Coronel acknowledged the first study’s limits, noting that it’s possible the participants would have been more likely to remember the data correctly if given explanations as to why the numbers didn’t fit expectations.
This is a limitation, however, that reflects the speed of the information gathering and sharing many do online. And that makes the study’s findings worth remembering: When sharing or consuming information, check it before relying upon it.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.