One of the highest responsibilities of citizenship is to serve as a juror, to judge a peer. It is, at once, a weighty burden and a privilege of American citizenry.

Some high school students are getting a taste of both by virtue of a program known as a youth court.

The youth courts are a true jury of one’s peers. Student volunteers sit as a jury to judge a fellow student who is in trouble.

The courts usually handle infractions of school rules, but some districts have expanded to handling minor offenses — keeping violators out of the juvenile justice system. That requires a more complex setup including a memorandum of understanding with police, prosecutors and judges.

Advertise with us

Youth courts are showing promise as a learning tool and a way to bring stray young people back into good behavioral patterns. Their expansion should be encouraged.

Youth courts work differently than the formal judicial system. When a student in trouble comes before a youth court jury, the student admits to the infraction of school rules or the violation. The youth courts impose a sentence of sorts, although that sentence is crafted based on evidence about the violation and the student in trouble.

A youth court sentence might include writing letters of apology, an essay or perhaps helping out janitorial staff if the student’s action caused extra work for janitors.

In the regular courts, juries typically make a decision about guilt or innocence and judges determine a sentence.

Youth courts can change the trajectory of a student in trouble. The courts aim at restorative justice, not punishment. It’s a chance at redemption for the young person gone astray. Instead of demerits on a school record that might affect a college application or scholarship, they’ll get the chance to save themselves.

Advertise with us

The jurors learn from the process. They learn the difficulty of making a decision about someone else’s life, evaluating a proper response to the violation. It’s a lesson in responsibility, and a lesson in mercy.

The youth courts are not a free pass and not all offending students are eligible. There are guidelines that serve to distinguish young people who might benefit from youth court from those whose offenses have gone beyond something the informal process can remedy.

Violent offenders aren’t going to youth court.

Enabling peers to offer the first chance at turning a student in trouble around before adults start to crack down is a fine idea. Youth courts make their own case as a learning and disciplinary tool more schools should adopt.

A start on gathering empirical data on youth court results is on the way. A state legislative advisory committee on youth courts in June recommended yearly reports by schools with youth courts be provided to the Pennsylvania Department of Education.

The expansion of youth courts should continue and be encouraged by school districts locally and throughout Pennsylvania.