The experience of salt truck drivers should trump computer algorithms when it comes to keeping Pittsburgh roads passable and safe during winter storms. Let the drivers make the call on salt spreading.
In Pittsburgh, winter storms bring snow, freezing rain, sleet and ice — sometimes all within an hour or two.
City officials want to save money by installing tablet computers in salt trucks. These tablets will monitor salt spreading. Supervisors sitting in the office and looking at computer screens will call drivers who are suspected of laying it on too thick so they can be warned to back off.
“Rogue” driver is the term Public Works Director Mike Gable used.
Mr. Gable told city council members that optimizing salt use could save Pittsburgh between $1.5 million and $2 million in salt during a regular winter. Here that means around 40 inches of snow.
If the city has rogue salt truck drivers, Pittsburgh has more problems than tablets on trucks can solve.
Cutting out the human element, the judgment and common sense of drivers out on the roads, is a bad idea.
Road safety shouldn’t be sacrificed to save money.
Technology is dandy, and city officials say the new system will save time for drivers. That’s all to the good. Technology has limits though. And micromanagement typically leads to no good end.
Hilly terrain or pockets of heavier snow or ice don’t need some formula about how much salt is optimal for a given road condition.
The rapidly shifting storms need drivers who have developed a grasp of what works in tricky weather conditions.
Sometimes good government isn’t about the dollar. In the case of winter storms, making the roads safe overrides cost.
Many people have to drive in winter conditions; snuggling on the couch is not an option for most.
Pittsburgh roads simply must be safe and passable. And the people with the boots on the ground — or behind the wheel of the salt truck, as the case may be — are in the best position to make the calls.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.