The Republicans started this.
It was the Republicans who defined impeachment down. No longer would it be a matter of grave seriousness for the nation. No, it would be political. And it would be personal.
The Republicans hated Bill Clinton and could not accept him as the president. And so impeachment, which Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution says shall be “for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors,” became, not a constitutional remedy but a weapon of raw, and ongoing, power politics.
It is not unreasonable to assume that, if President Donald Trump is re-elected, he will be impeached again.
It is not unreasonable to assume that the next Democratic president who faces a Republican House will be impeached.
This House impeached this president, not for treason or bribery or high crimes, but for obstruction of Congress and abuse of power. This lowers the standard for impeachment. This is a standard that could be applied to every president since Theodore Roosevelt.
And this is indisputably unwise.
One can search the Federalist Papers and the records of the Constitutional Convention for clear intent in the minds of the Founders on impeachment. One will search in vain.
What is clear, with apologies to those on the originalist spectrum, is that the Founders gave us the structure of a political system and expected us to make it work, in different ways, in real time and through time. And throughout American history, impeachment has been regarded as what we today would call “the nuclear option.”
Up until Richard Nixon, who was about to be impeached by the House before he resigned, impeachment had been invoked only once in almost two centuries. In the Nixon case, two sound principles were established: First, that impeachment would have to have some bipartisan support to move forward, and second, that it should be established that a crime was committed. We have now seen impeachment invoked twice in roughly 20 years. And in neither case was there support from the party of the president. In neither case was a “high crime” proven.
With Bill Clinton, the nuclear option was applied to a violation of decency and of norms (and lying about it under oath). The president was undignified. He demeaned his office and embarrassed the country. That might have been worthy of censure, or political defeat if he could have stood for election again. It was not worthy of impeachment.
A majority of Americans might easily agree that Donald Trump violated norms and decency, and sound policymaking, in playing hardball with the government of Ukraine, hoping to damage a political foe. But that only rises to the level of impeachment if impeachment is no longer nuclear but just one more weapon of political warfare.
By applying such a potent weapon to political conflict, we have plunged ourselves into a state of permanent political warfare — an endless politics of payback with no interruption for governing.
And this, in turn, means a politics of permanent division, with no bridges and no bridge builders.
The fact that there have been no surprises in the impeachment saga so far, that almost every actor in the drama has behaved in a way that was totally predictable, shows how broken our politics really is.
Read the responses of the Democrats and the Republican in the House to each other. What you heard was two angry tribes, with each tribe living completely in its own reality and granting zero recognition to the other’s reality. The Dems could not see any issue but the president’s personality. They hate him as the GOP hated Mr. Clinton and Barack Obama. The GOP could not admit that what the president did was wrong.
What now?
We go to the Senate for a trial. The trial should be sober, thorough and fair. It need not be long. It should not be a fresh fishing expedition. The House has acted as the grand jury. Each side should summarize its case and the Senate should vote with alacrity.
Nancy Pelosi and Mitch McConnell have already begun to play games with the Senate process, with the speaker wanting to delay sending the House’s charge and the majority leader looking for a way to elongate the trial (before the polls shifted, he wanted to simply dismiss it).
One of the results of endless political warfare without pause for governance is that there are no statesmen. The bullies and thugs lead, and no one stands up to them. Think of the people who have left politics in just the last four years. A Sam Ervin or a Wayne Morse, who stand above the fray, is impossible in this milieu.
On this matter, the Founders were clear. They wanted competition and a balancing of powers and interests. They did not want constant warfare. This is what Americans want, too, even today — especially today.
The Founders also expected there to be statesmen. Our citizens, today, long for them.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.