More security and less counseling, or more counseling and less security? Pittsburgh Public Schools is facing this question after a group of concerned parents urged the district to reallocate resources to bolster its counseling and mental health services. PPS, which is being forced to address difficult questions about its finances after administrators made a number of expensive trips (with dubious connections to educational development) over the past several years, is being asked to pick a side.

But social services and security need not be mutually exclusive, particularly not when shootings and other forms of violence are a routine threat in America.

There is room for PPS to improve its mental health services. The district’s 2020 budget would fund about 85 social service positions — 45 counselors and 40 social workers. But, with approximately 23,000 students, PPS would be providing one counselor for every 511 students. This figure lags behind the nationwide average of one counselor to every 455 students, and falls fall short of the recommended ratio — 250-to-1, according to the American School Counselor Association.

A research team led by Scott Carrell, then of Dartmouth College and now of the University of California, Davis, determined that a counselor ratio in line with the ASCA recommendation decreased the recurrence of student disciplinary problems and the number of students involved in a disciplinary incident. In other words, more robust social services help address issues that can later develop into the sorts of problems for which security is necessary.

Advertise with us

Worried parents spoke out at a recent PPS budget hearing. They admonished the district to hire more social service employees by lowering the number of budgeted security personnel — the 2020 budget would fund 92 such positions.

Press the pause button.

Violence and the threat of violence is a prominent issue in our nation’s schools. The nonprofit Educator’s School Safety Network reported that during the 2017-2018 school year, there were at least 3,380 threats made in K-12 schools, and at least 279 violent incidents (defined as involving weapons, significant injury or death). These figures represented increases of 60% and 113%, respectively, from the previous year.

Meanwhile, a study published in the Journal of Child and Family Studies found that from 2000 to 2018, the United States had already experienced “more deaths related to school shootings than in the whole 20th century.”

What was once “unthinkable” has become commonplace. Decreasing security may serve only to put more students at risk should the “unthinkable” happen yet again.

Advertise with us

This is not to suggest that PPS should continue with substandard staffing for social services. The district should find a way to hire more personnel to help students, but it should not have to compromise on security to do so. These sorts of compromises might not even be on the table had the PPS travel budget not mysteriously ballooned from $162,258 in 2016 to $453,231 in 2019. Imagine what the district could have achieved for its students with that extra $290,000.

Improved social services will be vital for PPS moving forward, but the district cannot afford any decision that could also sacrifice the immediate safety of its students.