A legislative effort to create the crime of “bullying” is under way in Pennsylvania. It’s an effort with the backing of prosecutors, but that is not enough. Lawmakers must seek input from educators and juvenile justice professionals, then generally proceed with caution on an issue of serious consequence.
House Bill 2053, a bipartisan measure co-sponsored by state Rep. Brandon Markosek, D-Monroeville, would add bullying to Pennsylvania’s crimes code as a third-degree misdemeanor. It would define the new crime as acting with the intent to “harass, annoy, alarm or intimidate another individual or group of individuals; or place another individual or group of individuals in fear of personal injury or property damage.”
The bill is aimed at addressing the most egregious cases of bullying. It contains addendums that would upgrade by a degree any other crime charged along with bullying. Lawmakers must ensure the law is written tightly enough that police and prosecutors can use it only in the most extreme cases.
The proposal’s prime sponsor, state Rep. Kyle Mullins, a Lackawanna County Democrat, said this measure is needed because prosecutors have told him that charges currently available to them in bullying situations generally limit penalties to a fine. Mr. Mullins contends that, under his bill, another, better option would be available. “The offender could be charged with a misdemeanor,” he said, “meaning that if he or she is a juvenile, they can get necessary treatment and resources needed to rehabilitate them.”
The Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association backs the bill and believes treatment would be the outcome for a juvenile adjudicated under its provisions. Greg Rowe, the association’s director of legislation and policy, said the state’s justice system for minors is geared toward rehabilitation. Adult bullies, he said, would face tougher consequences for intentionally causing someone anguish.
Caution and pause are warranted, however. A 2014 report by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advises school officials against using punitive measures on bullies, saying that a “focus on blame, shame, and criminalization is divisive and can be a roadblock to getting youth and families the professional support that is needed to make a positive change and prevent future suffering.”
State lawmakers must consider how this proposal would affect all schoolchildren, even the mean ones. Before making bullying an actual crime, they should make sure the juvenile justice system is ready to address the issue in a way that gets at the heart of the problem.
Mr. Mullins said the bill’s sponsors reached out to prosecutors first because they were seeking to change the state’s crimes code, and since have heard from parents of bullied children who want action. Parents of bullied children would be expected to favor this bill, as would prosecutors who are paid to prosecute.
Input from those segments is not enough. Mr. Mullins has acknowledged that “stakeholder feedback is critical” as the bill moves forward. He should usher the bill through hearings and invite comment from school administrators, professionals in the juvenile justice system, social workers and psychologists who work with bullied children as well as the bullies themselves. School officials should know their responsibilities for reporting bullying that rises to the bill’s standard for criminal behavior.
Bullying is a complex problem — being its victim or its perpetrator is considered by the CDC to be a risk factor for suicide. Lawmakers must weigh carefully this proposed bill before it becomes law.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.