The inventor of the World Wide Web says it’s time to come up with a tool kit and fix the thing. His goals are good, but one of the remedies offered during the recent rollout of his proposed remedy would threaten the First Amendment if adopted here in the United States.

Tim Berners-Lee, whose work on a global hypertext project in the late 1980s created the World Wide Web that went public in 1991, sees problems with how his creation is being used.

While he celebrates the web’s ability to spread information and serve humanity, Mr. Berners-Lee is alarmed by the spread of prejudice, hate and false information, identity theft, and the stalking and threatening of individuals that plague today’s online interactions.

The mechanism Mr. Berners-Lee offers to address these problems is the Contract for the Web, a voluntary collaboration of governments, tech companies and individuals who use the internet. It aims to expand access to the web, protect individual privacy and promote civil discourse.

Advertise with us

The contract’s goals are worthwhile: transparency about how government uses our data; making the web available and affordable across the globe; establishing privacy protections with high penalties for violations; preventing government censorship; and, in the contract’s own words, “developing mechanisms to ensure meaningful transparency for political advertising.”

The last goal is a good one. If tech companies such as Google, Facebook and Twitter can display political content in a way that helps citizens identify its true source, that could lead to better conversations about important issues.

But Mr. Berners-Lee and Adrian Lovett, president and CEO of the World Wide Web Foundation behind the contract, have expressed doubts that such tools can be developed in time to prevent serious abuses in upcoming elections.

Both have called for an immediate ban on targeted political advertising, which in their view would restore trust in public discourse. And both want government involved in policing political ads in the future.

Mr. Lovett has called on Facebook and Google to refuse political ads during Great Britain’s Dec. 12 elections for Parliament and supports legislative action to address political advertising online.

Advertise with us

Facebook and Google are free to handle political ads as they see fit but asking governments to get involved, in the short or long term, is an invitation to censorship.

Letting the state decide what political speech, including ads, will be allowed is at odds with the premise of the First Amendment: The truth prevails when all are allowed to make their cases, and it’s not government’s role to determine who speaks for truth.

That principle, the law of the land here in the United States, is a good one for any democracy or republic to respect. Any government that controls political speech comes under suspicion of skewing the outcome of elections, undermining its own legitimacy.

The fact that the First Amendment can be abused in high-tech ways today must not lead us to abandon the good sense that led to its adoption.

Government is a powerful tool, too powerful to sort fact from fiction in a political contest. Voters must be on their guard against misinformation. Individuals can demand accountability. Private institutions can help. But putting out a contract on free speech is not the answer.