The claim that Pennsylvania is ill-prepared for the impacts of climate change, as is argued in a new report released by state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale, seemed likely to inspire debate. But the flippant and counter-productive comments of state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry, serve only to derail the discussion and limit the opportunities for cooperation and compromise.

Typical for the (ahem) esteemed Mr. Metcalfe.

The conclusions of Mr. DePasquale’s report were striking. The auditor general reported that natural disasters caused by climate change had created more than $260 million in damage, paid for entirely by the state, in 2018. The damage was too localized for the commonwealth to secure federal aid, he said. Almost half of the expenditures went to repairing roads damaged by flooding and landslides.

Mr. DePasquale has proposed establishing a state disaster relief trust fund of at least $100 million to more effectively handle repairs. He also has supported Gov. Tom Wolf’s “Restore PA” plan to modernize state infrastructure. Mr. Wolf’s proposal would have the state borrow $4.5 billion to make improvements. The debt would then be paid off over 20 years with funds raised by a proposed severance tax on the natural gas industry.

Advertise with us

Climate change. The natural gas industry. Taxes. They are a veritable pressure cooker of hot-button topics in Pennsylvania politics. So it is no surprise that some members of the Legislature might not agree with Mr. DePasquale and the conclusions of his report.

The response of the perennial hot-head Mr. Metcalfe, however, went far beyond the boundaries of reasonable or respectful disagreement. The lawmaker from Butler County accused Mr. DePasquale in a news release of “Chicken Little fear-mongering” for disseminating an “alarmist” report and supporting the governor’s “delusional” climate policy.

Attacks of this kind would have no place in a race for student class president, let alone Pennsylvania state government.

Mr. Metcalfe is within his rights to disagree with Mr. DePasquale and Mr. Wolf on issues facing the state and any proposed solutions they may put forward. In his role as a state representative, though, Mr. Metcalfe is supposed to come up with his own solutions or back the plans of his colleagues, not engage in juvenile verbal attacks that debase political discourse.

It is all but certain Mr. Metcalfe has no sound or constructive ideas or solutions — on anything. His response to Mr. DePasquale’s report did not bother to address its findings with any specificity nor did he offer any alternatives to the auditor general’s suggestions.

Rather than lashing out (and despite little hope for success), Mr. Metcalfe should attempt a serious retort to Mr. DePasquale. Could he come up with something that can push the conversation forward and help ensure that Pennsylvanians have a safe, modern state for years to come? Probably not. We’re talking about Mr. Metcalfe. If he can’t muster the intellect or the willpower to say something useful, he shouldn’t say anything at all.