With pedestrian and cyclist deaths on the rise nationwide, according to federal data from 2018, cities everywhere must pursue more robust plans for protecting the lives of those who move along busy streets. The city of Pittsburgh already has its own traffic calming initiative, but the program could benefit from an expanded mission and revamped structure.
The city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure’s latest effort involves the installation of speed humps in four neighborhoods — the Hill District, Squirrel Hill, Highland Park and Carrick — meant to increase safety by slowing motorists. But speed humps should be just one tool among a broader package of roadway alterations and renovations that can make Pittsburgh’s streets more livable at a relatively low cost to taxpayers.
DOMI currently assesses potential traffic calming projects that meet four criteria: The roads must be owned by the city, have a maximum of two travel lanes, have a speed limit of 25 miles per hour and have a minimum vehicle volume of 1,000 vehicles per day.
The most pressing criteria for traffic calming should focus on reducing the danger posed to pedestrians and cyclists. This idea formed the basis of San Francisco’s ambitious Vision Zero SF, a city program launched in 2014 aimed at eliminating traffic fatalities by 2024. The program has made all of its efforts and all of its data publicly available on visionzerosf.org, thus their work is accessible and transparent.
Researchers with the program determined that 70% of severe and fatal collisions occurred on just 12% of San Francisco streets. This allowed engineers to design targeted safety improvements — protected bike lanes, wider sidewalks, roundabouts and more — that calmed traffic and improved safety and organization on some of the city’s most dangerous roadways.
While San Francisco may not be traffic fatality-free by 2024, Vision Zero SF’s lofty ambitions have made a difference, dropping the city’s death toll from 31 in 2013 to 23 in 2018.
Pittsburgh is safer for pedestrians compared to many comparably sized metro areas, according to data compiled by the urban development nonprofit Smart Growth America. Still, our city lost 211 pedestrians from 2008 to 2017. There is much room for improvement.
The city should study San Francisco’s program and similar initiatives throughout the country to improve the efficacy and impact of its traffic calming program. DOMI should identify the most dangerous roadways and work with engineers to create individualized solutions to better ensure pedestrian safety. Some improvements, such as narrowing roads, can be expensive, but others, such as the installation of curb extensions or medians, are not. The city already has experimented with some of these improvements, such as pedestrian refuge islands and flexible road posts. Those efforts should continue.
It is also important that DOMI make its work transparent and accessible, in much the same fashion as Vision Zero SF. Pittsburgh pedestrians deserve greater safety when moving about the city, and ready access to DOMI’s project slate and safety data will help improve accountability.
Pedestrian and cyclist deaths and injuries are often preventable. The data, strategies and policies needed to combat these tragedies are available. DOMI has made laudable advances in improving safety. Now, it is time to kick things up a notch.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.