Pittsburgh Public Schools’ new plan to reduce racial disparities within the district takes aim at a laudable and important goal. But PPS must proceed cautiously, regularly checking the successes and failures of its 27-step plan and reacting accordingly to ensure that every student is afforded the opportunity to succeed in a more equitable environment.
Racial achievement gaps are an issue at many schools throughout the state and the country, and PPS is no different. But the district has made meaningful strides in recent years with a set of small policy changes meant to chip away at the problem.
For instance, the school’s overall graduation rate improved by nearly 10%, growing from 70.4% in 2015 to 79.8% in 2016, and the rate of graduation for African American students rose more than 12% during that same period.
But the 77.4% overall black graduation rate still lags behind the 87.1% graduation rate of white students, just one sign that there is work to be done.
PPS’ plan, called “On Track to Equity, Integrating Equity Throughout PPS,” presents a bold, sweeping vision of the district’s future, outlining a set of changes meant to improve the school’s racial disparities. This new phase marks the beginning of what will be Superintendent Anthony Hamlet’s defining test. Addressing racial disparities in PPS’ education was the primary task assigned to Mr. Hamlet after his hiring in 2016. Mr. Hamlet, who has found himself embroiled in several controversies since his hiring, must get this project right.
That being said, working to reduce inequities in the PPS system is not about scoring victories for Mr. Hamlet or the school board. It is about helping kids. And PPS will have to pursue equity in all facets of educational experience — punishments, extracurricular participation, grades and test scores — to achieve real success.
In other words, “On Track to Equity” must be more than the latest and greatest shiny new thing. It must have real substance and consequential reforms that give every student a fair track and a meaningful opportunity at graduating and at pursuing fulfilling experiences, either at a college, trade school or in the workforce.
PPS has outlined 27 key steps, broken into seven categories, that it hopes will drive change within the district, giving teachers and students the resources and environment conducive to reducing the achievement gap in its schools. This includes improved professional development opportunities, the implementation of “culturally responsive instructional materials” and regular curriculum reviews to ensure that all students are enjoying the fruits of a rigorous education.
Essential to the success of this plan will be monitoring and assessment. PPS does not want to enact policies that amount to little more than politically correct pablum. PPS must pursue structural reform that allows all of its students to succeed. To this end, Mr. Hamlet was wise to staff a Data, Research, Evaluation and Assessment team. The group analyzes data related to areas like attendance, academic performance, discipline and more, and will study how the policy changes enacted by “On Track to Equity” affect those figures.
Through all this analysis and change, the students of PPS must always remain in the foreground. Sifting through reams of data can inform and motivate important change, but that data reflects the lives of real children. That humanity should remain the district’s guiding light as it seeks reform.
Paying lip service to equity is easy, even trendy. But actually achieving equity requires long, hard work. The results will not come easily. PPS should not be afraid to adjust its plans and adapt when necessary.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.