A recent complaint filed against the University of Pittsburgh because of the alleged mistreatment of lab animals should be a wake-up call to Pitt. The complaint has drawn attention to the lack of transparency and accountability in the current rules governing animal research.

The complaint, raised by Stop Animal Exploitation NOW!, a Milford, Ohio-based nonprofit, cites federal records that show two deaths and a serious injury to monkeys in Pitt’s labs. SAEN wants the U.S. Department of Agriculture to investigate the violations and fine Pitt $10,000 per incident, the maximum amount allowed.

This is not the first time an animal rights group has tangled with Pitt. SAEN has filed similar complaints against Pitt at least four times in the last 15 years. The nonprofit People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals repeatedly has criticized the university for its “cruel experiments,” highlighting research that involved causing mice to become addicted to cocaine.

Pitt denies any wrongdoing. Commenting on SAEN’s complaint, a university spokesman told the Post-Gazette’s Sean D. Hamill, “While incidents such as these are extremely rare, we strive for continuous improvement to prevent any such occurrence.”

Advertise with us

But exactly how many incidents have occurred in Pitt’s animal research labs? The answer is difficult to determine.

Pitt has not responded to media requests for an accounting of past incidents. The USDA, which performed an inspection in July at Pitt after the monkey incidents were reported, has inspection reports in its online database dating back only to 2017. The National Institutes of Health, which provides Pitt with funding, has no online database and provides records only in response to Freedom of Information Act requests. SAEN filed its complaint only after obtaining NIH records through such a request.

The lack of readily available animal testing records at Pitt is concerning. The lack of transparency looks suspicious. Lab testing of animals appears to be shrouded in secrecy to avoid scrutiny.

If Pitt wishes to make the case for the importance of its science, it should offer access and openness and face the consequences.