The seemingly endless torrent of scandal that has befallen Facebook over the past several years may have finally broken founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg. The beleaguered executive recently endorsed internet regulation, laying out a series of proposals in a Washington Post op-ed.

But much as his recent missive on improving privacy on Facebook had to be met with raised eyebrows, these proposals, too, should face considerable skepticism.

Some of what Mr. Zuckerberg has proposed — admittedly in sweeping, vague terms — is smart and refreshing. His calls for regulations that would support “election integrity, privacy and data portability,” which would allow users greater access to control their personal data online, are all sound.

But there are two significant concerns with Mr. Zuckerberg’s sudden embrace of regulation.

Advertise with us

The first involves free expression online. In his essay, Mr. Zuckerberg asserts that legislators must hold companies like his own “accountable for enforcing standards on harmful content.” But, as is the case with all questions of speech regulation, who is so impartial, so clear-minded, as to set clear guidelines for what is and is not permissible speech? The answer, of course, is that no one is capable of such a feat.

Still, the mass shooting in New Zealand and the graphic video of the attack were an important reminder that serious ethical questions do exist about “harmful content” and that they cannot merely be waved away.

That’s why legislators should not look to Mr. Zuckerberg on this question, but instead the U.S. Supreme Court. In fact, five civil liberties organizations — the American Civil Liberties Union, the Brennan Center for Justice at the New York University School of Law, the Center for Democracy & Technology, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and New America’s Open Technology Institute — recently published a document emphasizing 10 key First Amendment principles that would better guide regulations than the whims of Mr. Zuckerberg.

The other concern regarding Mr. Zuckerberg’s hallelujah moment is a question of motive. Why has the Facebook CEO, a man who has profited greatly off abusing the infrastructure of the internet, abruptly decided it would be better to hamstring himself and others?

No one but Mr. Zuckerberg himself may be able to answer that question, but one has to suspect that the looming specter of antitrust action, as proposed by Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., may have gotten him spooked. But whatever the case, people across the country and throughout the world have ample reason to doubt Mr. Zuckerberg’s sincerity.

Advertise with us

Lawmakers can certainly take Mr. Zuckerberg’s proposals into account — he does put forth several decent foundational ideas — but the people and the internet would be better served by legislation devised by independent technical experts and guided by Supreme Court case law. A better, safer internet is attainable, but it will not be devised by Mark Zuckerberg.