Elizabeth Warren wants to break up Big Tech.
The Democratic senator from Massachusetts recently laid out her vision for antitrust action against Amazon, Facebook and Google, citing each company’s laundry list of anti-competitive practices that have created what is essentially a monopolistic market.
Through the use of stricter regulations and the reversal of large mergers, Ms. Warren’s proposal would seek to bring fairness and balance to the digital marketplace, a change that could help restore economic competitiveness and, in turn, heal the wounds inflicted upon our civic life.
According to Ms. Warren, as each of these companies has grown larger and amassed more power — all three are among the five most valuable companies in the world — “they have used their resources and control over the way we use the internet to squash small businesses and innovation, and substitute their own financial interests for the broader interests of the American people.”
By acquiring hundreds of other companies, Amazon, Facebook and Google control a disproportionate amount of internet traffic and commerce. Ninety percent of all internet searches go through Google. The search engine giant and Facebook account for 58 percent of digital ads. And Amazon accounts for nearly 50 percent of all e-commerce spending.
On the way to amassing this enormous power, each company has been able to buy out meaningful competitors and price out lesser ones. Amazon snatched up Whole Foods, Facebook snagged WhatsApp and Instagram, and Google alone has made over 200 acquisitions, including YouTube. By reversing and blocking these mergers, other tech companies would suddenly be able to compete with the behemoths.
Read More
And, as Ms. Warren has noted, “Healthy competition can solve a lot of problems.”
But as one might imagine, the companies in question have not responded well to this proposal and others like it. Each company has spent millions of dollars lobbying against stricter regulations on the tech world. Google has even been financing professors to write papers defending its market dominance.
But in reacting to Ms. Warren’s recent proposal, one of these companies — Facebook — fell right into a trap.
The senator purchased Facebook ads noting that effective campaign messaging in the 21st century can only be achieved through social media giants, thus highlighting their disproportionate grasp on our democracy. Facebook censored the ads. And while the ensuing backlash has forced Facebook to reverse its decision, the initial censorship went a long way toward proving Ms. Warren’s point.
The size and ubiquity of companies like Amazon, Facebook and Google have left many Americans feeling helpless, as though there is nothing to be done to limit their power on our economy, on our businesses or on our lives. Ms. Warren’s proposal reminds us that, in actuality, our politicians possess the tools necessary to level the playing field and protect our democracy. The companies are big, but they are not sovereign.
Ms. Warren has admitted that antitrust action is not a cure-all. But her proposals for breaking up America’s Big Tech companies are a good place to start, offering a road map for a digital market that prioritizes fair competition over profit maximization.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.