A federal judge has, rightly and thankfully, underscored what should be obvious: Pennsylvania’s chief prosecutor should not be denied his David-versus-Goliath battle to foil UPMC’s quest for dominance of Pennsylvania’s health care landscape.

Judge John E. Jones III from the Middle District dismissed UPMC’s challenge of state Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s authority to open and modify a five-year consent decree that will expire in a matter of weeks. The end of the consent decree will restrict access to UPMC doctors and facilities for thousands of Western Pennsylvanians who subscribe to Highmark insurance.

The federal decision concludes that state government — in the guise of Mr. Shapiro-cum-David — has not acted improperly in stating his intent to change the consent decree which has allowed ever-diminishing degrees of cross-network access the past five years. (On July 1, most of the remaining Highmark subscribers allowed in-network access to UPMC-cum-Goliath — sick people with chronic conditions as well as the elderly — will be barred.)

Mr. Shapiro is facing a formidable foe: the state’s largest employer, the region’s biggest landowner, a “business” run by high-powered execs who make millions. But the AG is determined — and he is among the few who are.

Advertise with us

Unlike his political counterparts at the federal, county and city levels who have done nothing to get in the way of this slow-motion train wreck, Mr. Shapiro worked for two years to negotiate new terms between UPMC and Highmark — terms that Highmark accepted but UPMC rebuffed. Then he used one of the few arrows left in his quiver and filed suit against the $19 billion-a-year health care behemoth with seemingly endless legal resources. (No surprise UPMC has money to spend on lawyers, and lots of them: This enterprise — we choke when calling it a charity — gets billions of dollars in federal grants, in philanthropic donations and in forgiven tax payments because of its status as a so-called nonprofit.)

Predictably, UPMC countered the AG’s office in Commonwealth Court then, for good measure, launched a federal suit in the Middle District.

We pray all the judges involved in UPMC’s legal maneuvers are endowed with the wisdom of Solomon. UPMC — all too willing to split the baby so long as it doesn’t have to lose the argument — can appeal this most recent decision and assuredly will, despite its losing streak. (It lost another federal court battle in Alabama days ago when it sought to intervene in an action that would force Blue Cross Blue Shield to allow its plans across the country to do business in Pittsburgh. It was ironic considering UPMC’s legal fight in Pennsylvania to snub the Blue in its own backyard.)

The only way any of this makes sense is under one scenario: that UPMC and its CEO Jeffrey Romoff are on a mission to crush Highmark and its health system, the Allegheny Health Network.

Before the next court filing, UPMC should engage in some soulful reflection:

Advertise with us

At what cost victory? The health and care of some of the neediest among us.