The message was stark and straightforward, unequivocally heart-piercing and nearly desperate:

Critically ill and injured children — kids from my neighborhood — need me now, said the solicitation that came to my home mailbox from UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh.

The correspondence assured me that my past donations had “made a lifesaving difference for a very sick child.”

But, more critically ill and injured children need me now, the note continued in a typeface of bold, black ink. My donation will help provide treatment and care to kids facing serious illnesses.

Advertise with us

The tear-off portion of the solicitation featured a box with a red check mark beside the words: “YES! I want to provide lifesaving care for critically sick and injured boys and girls” from my very own town. The postage-paid envelope had a special message squeezed aside the return address: “Thank you for your support!” in a font made to look like a child’s scrawl with a heart in place of an “O” in the word “your.”

■    ■    ■

Is there a person in Western Pennsylvania who hasn’t contributed at some point in one form or another to Children’s Hospital? Someone who hasn’t written a check; bought a “farkleberry” cookie; tossed change into a jar at the grocery checkout; gone on a Christmas house tour for the Free Care Fund; phoned into a telethon; paid admission to a benefit dance performance?

I got a letter from UPMC;
Here’s one to Jeffrey Romoff from me


To: Jef­frey Ro­moff, CEO of UPMC
64th Floor, gilded ea­gles nest of the U.S. Steel Tower

Dear Mr. Ro­moff,

Your gift to Western Penn­syl­va­nia in 2014 — a court-sanc­tioned-and-su­per­vised agree­ment to re­luc­tantly al­low your tax­payer-funded, phil­an­throp­ically-sup­ported “non­profit” hos­pi­tal sys­tem to con­tinue treat­ing sick peo­ple, re­gard­less of their brand of in­sur­ance — made a life­sav­ing dif­fer­ence for a very sick child. (And a ter­mi­nal can­cer pa­tient. And a scared and con­fused se­nior cit­i­zen.)

We wanted you to know that more crit­i­cally ill and in­jured chil­dren (and dy­ing pa­tients and scared and con­fused se­niors) need you now. Your con­tri­bu­tions — un­der the aus­pices of your glob­ally rec­og­nized UPMC hos­pi­tal sys­tem — are the rea­son (some of) our loved ones who need you are re­ceiv­ing care. (At least for a few more weeks/months.)

Your do­na­tion — of more time, via an ex­ten­sion of your con­sent de­cree with High­mark in­sur­ance or even a re­newed will­l­ng­ness to talk with your en­emy — will help pro­vide treat­ment and care to peo­ple fac­ing se­ri­ous ill­ness.

Thank you for re­new­ing your com­mit­ment to your pa­tients.

Sincerely,

Karen Kane, on be­half of sick peo­ple with the “wrong” in­sur­ance ev­ery­where

Our community has been giving and giving to Children’s Hospital virtually since its founding in 1890. And our dollars — millions upon millions of them — have transformed the facility into one of the world’s leading pediatric hospitals.

What we as a community have asked in return has been given: quality care for our sons and daughters, our grandchildren, the kids down the street — care at affordable prices and sometimes at no cost at all for those who couldn’t afford to pay.

Advertise with us

It has seemed a fair arrangement. Until now.

Now, the rules of engagement are changing.

■    ■    ■

All too soon, UPMC Children’s — the only hospital in Western Pennsylvania dedicated solely to the treatment of infants, children and young adults — will no longer treat patients who are covered by Highmark insurance plans. A simmering contretemps over reimbursement rates between the largest health care provider (UPMC) and the largest insurer (Highmark) exploded into a full-blown breakup. Then UPMC started its own insurance brand. Then Highmark bought a health system. Then UPMC stopped talking to Highmark. Then divorce attorneys worked out a deal that slowly unraveled cross-network access. On July 1, most of the remaining Highmark customers doing business with UPMC — the elderly and those who are considered medically vulnerable — will join the ranks of the regular Highmark folk who have been all but barred from UPMC premises.

Children’s Hospital is an exception, for now. Highmark customers will be allowed entry at in-network prices through 2022.

Advertise with us

■    ■    ■

I know what it is to need the services of UPMC Children’s. A dearly loved member of my extended family has contended with a medical condition since middle childhood. Before we landed at Children’s, her journey was fraught with mysterious symptoms and misdiagnoses. Children’s Hospital set her path aright. We were — we are — grateful for the dedicated, skilled professionals and the state-of-the-art facilities that have been an integral part of her life.

When I saw the UPMC solicitation in my mail, I was indignant.

It wasn’t the unabashed manipulation of my heart strings, the words used to create a sense of immediate crisis — a crisis I had a personal obligation to mitigate.

What offended me was my memory of a sentence from a recent UPMC court filing, penned by a UPMC attorney. Here it is:

Advertise with us

“Nowhere does UPMC’s charitable mission say that UPMC must provide high-quality accessible health care to everyone at in-network rates...”

What that means is this: We’ve been played.

Our towns have foregone tax revenue to further UPMC’s mission.

Our philanthropic foundations have given to their cause.

We’ve plucked bills from our wallets, drafted checks from our bank accounts, pledged donations on the internet.

Advertise with us

All because we really believed that UPMC — especially Children’s — was, indeed, a mission-driven charity committed to healing the sick and caring for the poor.

Now, we know we’ve been wrong. Now, we know that UPMC’s real mission is to crush the competition. This so-called nonprofit — this purveyor of life-changing medicine — actually is a wolf of industry cloaked in the clothing of a charitable lamb.

I won’t be giving any money to UPMC Children’s Hospital, and not just because I’m a Highmark subscriber. I won’t give to a hospital that doesn’t open its doors to all in need. If Children’s wants my charity, it should want my business, too.

Karen Kane is a Post-Gazette editorial board member (kkane@post-gazette.com, 724 772-9180). Follow her on Twitter @KarenKanePG.