With limited time and resources, thousands of police departments throughout the country have turned to for-profit private companies to write their departmental policies. Lexipol, a California company, has emerged as the most popular purveyor of these ready-made policies; an article published in the Texas Law Review referred to Lexipol as the “dominant force in police policymaking across the country.”
But Lexipol, which serves approximately 3,400 police, fire and correctional agencies in 35 states, has no public oversight and there are few mechanisms for accountability. In fact, the open-ended language used in Lexipol-written policies seems to be geared more toward offering police departments legal cover rather than guidelines for good policing.
For example, Bruce Praet, one of the founders of Lexipol, wrote a blog post in 2017 discouraging police departments from enacting policy changes that would limit when officers can deploy force. The changes had been recommended by 11 law enforcement organizations, including the Fraternal Order of Police. But Mr. Praet wrote that the language in the recommended changes would make certain restraint-oriented provisions mandatory, thus opening departments up to lawsuits if they were violated.
In other public statements, Mr. Praet has advocated for limiting policies restricting the use of force to what is required by law, a far cry from what has been recommended by the 11 law enforcement organizations and criminal justice experts.

“On a broader basis, agencies should not become more restrictive than what officers have learned to function under as dictated by the Supreme Court,” Mr. Praet said in an interview with the criminal justice website The Appeal.
Andrea Pritchett, a police review commissioner in Berkeley, Calif., told the website Citylab that Lexipol policies focus more on protecting the departments than citizens. “They’re designed for maximum protection against civil liability,” she said. “It’s not maximum protection of civil rights.”
This should be troubling for residents throughout the country, particularly those who reside in less-populated areas more likely to enlist companies such as Lexipol. (Police departments in larger cities, like New York, can afford in-house policymakers.) That police policy is being written up not to protect the rights of citizens but with the interests of the police in mind is antithetical to the American virtue of prioritizing the individual over the state.
It may require more time and resources, but police departments should craft more thoughtful policies that serve their local populations well and ensure that good, lawful policing can be carried out. Consulting the community and the recommendations of national law enforcement agencies is a good place to start.
Using companies like Lexipol is an easy way out and, when it comes to policing, the easy way out can often have dangerous repercussions.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.